Less-than-fluid pan


I was tempted to read more than is probably there in the pan across the desert which can be seen at the end of the film's original trailer-

(http://www.sonyclassics.com/thepassenger/trailer_content.html)

In the theatre (the web version doesn't have enought resolution for this) the pan is remarkably uneven, almost stops and starts as it progresses. I was trying to figure if there was a point to this, or if it simply represented a situation where one had to use a less-than-perfect take for technical reasons...

Earlier in the film there's a remarkable use of pan in contravention of one's expectations: the camera pans (again to the right) as the sound of Locke's truck grows louder. We think we're panning to meet the truck when it comes rushing past us on the left...

reply

yes I agree a number of the pans are rather shaky and less-than-fluid yet not really too detracting from the film's quality IMO

reply

I think they are deliberate, symbolising somebody looking for something and not sure where to find it.

reply

Sometimes I think there is an almost Brechtian/Epic Theatre direction in Antonioni's films. I know he likes to film his films from a third perspective, in a sense that he is standingt here silently watching what is going on, participating in every scene but doesn't speak, but looks where he wants to look, but in that sense, relating to the Epic Theatre theory, that he's almost quite happy for you to be aware that this is a film you're watching and that camera with the jerky pan is really there and is breaking from reality of the film.

Antonioni is obsessed with alienation in his films, and the theory behind epic theatre is that no one watching it should buy into it as a reality, that one must always be aware that they are watching a staged performance, and perhaps this is Antonioni's way of using that theory, and alienating us, the audience, from what is going, because the characters are alienated from their surroundings so why then should we buy into their story and sympathise with it, maybe he chooses to alienate us as well. I think that's what he does, because he gives us so little information and so much ambiguity that we find it difficult to know what's going on in his films and find it difficult to relate. We only seem to be able to relate to the isolation.

reply

It's possible Antonioni deliberately wanted the pan to be jerky.

Alternatively, it's also possible they used gear heads instead of the modern fluid or hydraulic heads that can be handled without a great deal of experience.

reply