Finally Got the DVD


I have seen this movie years ago but it was good to get the DVD so I can see it whenever I want. I have a great collection of films featuring BDSM now, including Secretary (my fave), La Prisonniere, a very sexy film that doesn't seem very well known in this country, Nine 1/2 Weeks, which I used to think was hot but I think I must have been left out in the sun too long when I thought that. I was disappointed in it this time.

I was pleased that the movie followed the book so closely, especially in the beginning. Some changes included Pierre and Jacqueline falling in love with O. I preferred the original, especially the part about Jacqueline. She was supposed to be a b*tch who was totally self-centered. Of course, the ending was changed considerably. I didn't care for her burning Sir Stephen but then I didn't care for his abandoning her in the book either. Maybe Pauline Reage didn't believe a Master-Slave relationship could have a "happily ever after" ending. La Prisonniere ended tragically too. Maybe it's this feeling that s/m is such a transgression that the characters must come to a bad end. I loved that Secretary had a happy ending. I guess it's just the American in me. :)

Anyway, this is a Story of O board, not a Secretary board so, to get back to O, I thought the movie was very well done. I'm glad I have it in my library.

Terry
Your soul and your body are your own, and yours to do with as you wish.

reply

I bought the dvd out of curiousity, because I've heard about it much or read something of it, but I haven't read the book, I think it's worthwhile to at least watch for something out of the ordinary, the only thing I don't like on the dvd is that the director's commentary goes about halfway through the movie & cuts off.

reply

I know. Isn't that odd? Maybe that's what they do in France. Have shorter commentaries, that is.

Terry
Your soul and your body are your own, and yours to do with as you wish.

reply

How strange! I've never listened to the commentary on that film. Maybe they figured the viewer wouldn't be able to stick with it any longer than halfway through!


Woman is the Earth and Man is the Sky.

reply

kia-1: "I have seen this movie years ago but it was good to get the DVD so I can see it whenever I want."

So I take it the DVD itself is of good quality then? It looks and sounds OK, no problems?


kia-1: "I have a great collection of films featuring BDSM now, including Secretary (my fave), La Prisonniere, a very sexy film that doesn't seem very well known in this country, Nine 1/2 Weeks, which I used to think was hot but I think I must have been left out in the sun too long when I thought that. I was disappointed in it this time."

Secretary (2002) rules.

After that the great erotic S& M genre movies are ... I haven't seen much that I like.


kia-1: "I was pleased that the movie followed the book so closely, especially in the beginning. Some changes included Pierre and Jacqueline falling in love with O. I preferred the original, especially the part about Jacqueline. She was supposed to be a b*tch who was totally self-centered. Of course, the ending was changed considerably. I didn't care for her burning Sir Stephen but then I didn't care for his abandoning her in the book either. Maybe Pauline Reage didn't believe a Master-Slave relationship could have a "happily ever after" ending. La Prisonniere ended tragically too. Maybe it's this feeling that s/m is such a transgression that the characters must come to a bad end. I loved that Secretary had a happy ending. I guess it's just the American in me. :) "

This of course is why I like Americans. :)

I like the ending in the movie version of Story Of O very much. I think it's the best thing in the movie. It's forceful, but ambiguous, and you can have the ever-after you want.

If you want, O is finally retaliating, which breaks the basis of the relationship and re-establishes the iron law of hopelessness: no good can come of this.

If you prefer, as I do, O is establishing firmly that the chain has two ends: she is held, and she holds, and she will not be abandoned as she was in the book. (An ending I did not like at all.) This is the best of endings.


kia-1: "Anyway, this is a Story of O board, not a Secretary board so, to get back to O, I thought the movie was very well done. I'm glad I have it in my library."

Assuming the DVD is worthy of the movie, I will be happy to have it too.

reply

The DVD I have looks and sounds just fine; it has the slight fadiness one expects of a film of the era, but it had that when I saw it in the theater over twenty years ago (in other words, it hasn't been given a new digital veneer or anything but is a true copy). My copy has no glitches or other such oddities.

Woman is the Earth and Man is the Sky.

reply

Thanks, that's all I needed to know. I'll buy it.

reply

It's good.

reply

I'm disappointed the UK version & I beleive the US version is dubbed into English with no original language option available!

The only one for sale presently in French Lang to my knowledge is the Japanese version.

reply