My favorite McQueens: The Magnificent Seven, The Great Escape, Bullitt, The Getaway, The Towering Inferno; honorable mention, with some reservations: The Blob, Never So Few, The Cincinnati Kid, The Sand Pebbles, Papillon.
My favorite Newmans: Somebody Up There Likes Me, The Rack, Until They Sail, Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, The Young Philadelphians, From the Terrace, Exodus, The Hustler, Hud, Hombre, Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, The Sting, The Towering Inferno, Slap Shot, The Verdict, Nobody's Fool; honorable mention, with some reservations: The Long Hot Summer, The Prize, The Drowning Pool, Absence of Malice, Mr. & Mrs. Bridge.
I should put a word in for Paul's disastrous film debut, The Silver Chalice, an incredibly bizarre Biblical epic that is awful beyond description despite a great cast, with some of the weirdest sets in Hollywood history. When the movie hit TV in the 60s Newman himself took an ad out in the trades apologizing for having ever made what he called "The worst film of the 50s." Not quite, but pretty stupid.
Most McQueen movies simply don't interest me very much, though like you I also found his last, The Hunter, not so bad; its terrible reviews always mystified me a little. Certainly not great, nor even among my favorites, but okay.
Newman overall had more range, while McQueen had more personal appeal.
Yeah, I'd agree with that.
reply
share