gay subplot


did this version of the film include the part of the novel where nick has sex with another man?

reply

Wow! Time to revisit the book. I don't remember that at all. Of course, I read it in high school over 30 years ago. Maybe I just didn't get it. I was naive to things like that back then. There was nothing like that in this movie. Although, Sam Waterston's Nick IS something of a sexual cypher.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

He/She isnt really messing , in the book after Tom and mrytles party nick tells how he ends up in a room when he was drunk with a man from the party in his underwear and then wakes up again in the train station at something like 5 in the morning.

reply

Nick didn't sleep with that man, that man was a photographer with a wife. Nick gets drunk and describes the rest of the night - including how he was bored listening to the photographer talk about his work. He eventually falls asleep that night but due to his drunkedness he can't recall when he fell asleep, the only thing he remembers is listening to the photographer and then waking up and taking the elevator to the train station. There's no gay subtext, just that he fell asleep due to boredom and because he was drunk, couldn't specifically remember when.

reply

No, when he woke up he definitely said it was in his underwear. Other than that, there's not much mention.

--
We are all in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars.
--Oscar Wilde

reply

I just finished reading the book for school, and I'm glad to see I'm not the only one who got that. XD This is in reference to the photographer being in bed and Nick in his underwear, right?

reply

No, but Sam Waterston, a fine actor, played him as either a gay man or a repressed homosexual (the way he looked at Gatsby), which is the only way the book makes sense. Jay Gatsby/James Gatz is hardly "Great" unless you are in love with him, which Nick clearly is.

---------------------------------------------
"Why do people always laugh in the wrong places?"
--John Dos Passos

reply

It's obvious that Nick's feelings for Jay were much stronger than Daisy's -- and I have to say Sam Waterston's performance was a lot more convincing than Mia Farrow's.

reply

I think that Sam Waterston does give the best performance in the film and he gives Nick a strong emotional attraction to Gatsby.

The remake's Nick, Tobey McGuire , fails to engage the viewer's emotions the way Waterston does. He doesnt bring much depth to the character.

reply

No.

And I have doubts that we will ever see that scene in a movie. And it should be in the movie because it calls into question Nick's reliability as a narrator.

All signs point to Gatsby being a violent criminal wearing pink suits and a would be social climber. Meanwhile Nick paints him as this sincere guy.

Which is reality and what is a crush?

reply

Neither this nor the 2013 film touch the subject. You'd need to REALLY want to ignore the author's innuendo to not figure out this scene (after Myrtle's party.)

Nick's romanticizing of Gatsby is already suspect and then, in hindsight, pretty clearly love. But that scene and Nick's hopeless female relationships (Jordan being mannish at least gives it a shot)clearly inform what the author could not say. The subtext gives it some interesting layers.

reply

No, because it didn't happen in the book.

Nick leaves the party with Mr. McKee after Tom cracks Myrtle across the chops. Nick goes to the McKees--who live in the same building as Tom and Myrtle's "flat"--to see Mr. McKee's work. MCKEE was the one in his underwear.

But the reference by other posters to Nick's role as narrator is accurate. Nick refers to himself as the most honest person he has ever known, for instance. He remarks on certain aspects of Gatsby's character and admits regarding him with unaffected scorn, yet also describes as one of those machines that can detect earthquakes.

Nick contradicts himself several times, yet tells an awesome story. As he says, it wasn't Gatsby who was "bad", it was what "preyed on Gatsby". Nick admired the fact Gatsby KNEW there was rumor and innuendo flying around, that people were leeching off him at his parties, etc. But he didn't care because of his singular aim of attaining Daisy.

As Nick said, "He had come a long way to this blue lawn..."

reply