MovieChat Forums > Death Wish (1974) Discussion > Rank the Death Wish Films

Rank the Death Wish Films


I looked around the IMDb forums for the Death Wish films and I couldn't find a thread for this, so let's rank the Death Wish flicks. I've seen each one at least three times, so these are my rankings:

1. Death Wish 3 (10/10)

Repeated viewing. One of the all-time great motion pictures, movies don't come much more ridiculous than this. The action scenes are both funny and exciting and the musical score (credited to Jimmy Page) is a delight. From the get-go, it feels like a cartoon. What's up with the police station's wanted poster for horses? Plus, Martin Balsam plays a guy named "Bennett," making this one of two '80s action masterpieces with a character to have that name (the other is, do I really have to say it?, Commando). There's plenty of lines that made me laugh out loud ("S**t, man, I'm hurt," for example) and the whole thing feels like the most epic of the series (it's also the best of the franchise). It's a bonkers flick.

2. Death Wish 4: The Crackdown (9/10)

This one holds up quite well. J. Lee Thompson's directing adds a bit of class to the film and there's plenty of well-orchestrated action. The plot pretty much comes to stand-still for the scenes of action/violence, and, normally, that'd be a bad thing, but I think they really pulled it off here. Gotta love that "I [heart] New Wave" bumper sticker on the van that Bronson blows to Hell with a grenade launcher. Danny Trejo shows up for a small part, which is certainly welcome. Overall, this is the series' second best.

3. Death Wish (8/10)

This has gotta be the most well-made of the series, although it's not quite the most entertaining (in that regard, I'd rank third in the franchise). It's a great piece of audience manipulation, really making you root for Bronson's vigilante character by showing the terrible conditions of the United States' urban areas and heinous crimes committed by the lowlifes who inhabit them. It's a bit more balanced in its depiction of vigilante justice than its sequels. showing Bronson barfing in a toilet after his first kill, Bronson never killing the thugs who killed his wife and raped his daughter, and Bronson being arrested at the end.

4. Death Wish II (8/10)

This slimy 'n' grimy sequel ups the amount of action from the first one, but doesn't quite have the same magic as that one. That being said, it's better than I remember and has moved from my least favorite of the series to my second-to-least favorite. Bronson is at his coldest here, killing scumbags with no mercy or remorse. I actually liked the subplot with Bronson's fiance, as it upped the stakes of Bronson's vigilante spree (he may lose the woman he loves if she discovers how he spends his nights). Laurence Fishburne's boombox death is highlight.

5. Death Wish V: The Face of Death (8/10)

Even though this one has a relatively low body count, I think it's the most violent of the franchise. It's pretty brutal at times. Anyway, I loved the bald goon who dual-wields Uzis and has a Dr. Claw voice (I think his name was "Frankie"). Almost every kill counts and there's some unintentionally funny moments (a good thing). Still, it's the weakest of the series, with its low budget (that makes it look like a made-for-T.V. movies) and its low number of kills for Bronson. I enjoyed it thoroughly nonetheless.

reply

I'd say Death Wish is the best movie by far, while Death Wish 3 is the best Death Wish movie...

reply

That doesn't make any sense. which do u think is best 1 or 3?

reply

Makes sense to me.

reply

3
1
2
4
5

I enjoy then all except 5 pure dung

reply

1. Death Wish II
The second act of this movie is what immediately comes to mind when I think of a Death Wish film. In fact, when you see parodies of Death Wish or of Charles Bronson, it's often him wearing the knit cap and the black jacket, carrying a gun and blowing away two-bit street punks in a darkened city. Those scenes are so engaging to me that I completely forgive whatever the movie lacks. The music is awesome. The characters he encounters on the street are fascinating. And I love how Paul is constantly casting a large shadow wherever he goes. I don't deny the griminess of this sequel but I find the overall tone (especially of that second act) to be perfect.

2- Death Wish
"What's gaining on you, Paul?" I don't know why but that line has always struck me as one of the best of the franchise. It seems to explain something deep about Bronson's character. In this movie, he's a haunted man, slowly spiraling into a kind of madness. It just so happens this particular madness seems to keep his demons at bay. Or does it? Anyway, I find myself right there with him as I watch. I love this character and his "origin story" is one of the best of any vigilante film I've seen.

3- Death Wish 4: The Crackdown
I have always preferred Paul Kersey as a lone vigilante with a bit of that "haunted" side I mentioned above. This movie brings all that back yet tries to maintain the over-the-top fun of Part 3. I think the balance is good. I also like that he goes after the fat cat criminals at the top... cutting off the head of the snake, so to speak, rather than just killing muggers and lowlifes. The bad guys in this movie are wealthy, penthouse dwellers who attend the opera and throw lavish parties. It's an interesting shift in tone that turns some viewers off. This sequel definitely feels different but I love it. And the ending... Oh my goodness! What a jaw dropping thing to happen just before rolling credits!

4- Death Wish 3
I know some will think I'm ranking this too low. Just keep in mind I give ALL the first four films in this series a 10 out of 10 on IMDB. So it's actually very hard to say which I enjoy more. I guess the one and only reason I put this below parts 1, 2 and 4 is because Paul becomes more of a war general in this one, leading a neighborhood into battle. Not that I mind this. I just slightly prefer him as the lone vigilante (as said above). But it can't be denied that this movie is a fun, action-packed, wonderfully goofy bit of 80s cheese that I enjoy every time I watch it. Cannon Films excelled at this sort of thing (see "Revenge of the Ninja" for another excellent example).

5- Death Wish V: The Face of Death
While I don't hate this movie, I just feel it's a poor follow-up to where Paul was at the end of Part 4. That movie's conclusion seemed to suggest a new direction for his character. When he drops his gun and walks off into the city, not even caring if the cop shoots him in the back... It was poignant! It's hard to imagine him going off to find yet another girlfriend and proposing marriage to her (even if 5 years have passed). Yet that's precisely what happens in Death Wish V. It feels generic and dishonest. Furthermore, the "fashion district" setting doesn't work for me. It's like they wanted to capture that "going after the guys at the top" thing again but left out the over-the-top fun. This movie is not a goofy romp like Part 3 or a shadowy, tense, "eerily exciting" film like of Parts 1 and 2. It's just uninspired and often rather dull. A definite misfire (sorry about the pun). Sadly, it was the end of the Paul Kersey story. I wish they had done more of a "come full circle" type story.

reply

This is really hard for me to say. As a stand alone movie and from a purely movie-making standpoint, I think the first is the best movie and most well-done. But my personal favorite is by far 3. 3 has that repeated viewing appeal. I can literally watch that one 20 times a year and it never gets old. It's just a lot of fun to watch. Almost like a really violent cartoon for adults. lol

3, 1, 4, 2, 5.
I would say I like I, III and IV almost equally for different reasons with III just winning by an edge. II, while still entertaining and pretty good, is just not quite on the same level. And then V is just kind of meh and actually not very good.




reply

None of them are bad IMO but I'd say
1, 3, 2, 4, 5

reply

1) Original
2) II

Whatever...

reply

2, 3, 1, 4, 5

reply