MovieChat Forums > Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore (1975) Discussion > Nice movie but one of the main plot them...

Nice movie but one of the main plot theme does not make sense at all....




Alice wants to move from Socorro to Monterey to rebuild her life as singer....planning to get there by fall when Tommy starts school again and stopping along the way to work and earn some money...ok...well....the problem is that Socorro to Monterey is only a 16 hours trip, according to Google....if she really wanted to get to Monterey she could do so in less than 2 days...only one hotel stop!
It is probably less cos effective to stop in the middle and looking for job (you have to eat and sleep) if you really have a clear destination in mind.
She should have been easily able to scrape the few dollars needed (again, only one motel stop needed and you can have few cheap meals) to do the trip all at once before leaving.
The "go to Monterey" should have been played more along the lines of a state of mind, in my opinion, than a real immediate objective, with the trip being more of an excuse to do some soul searching than a "go from A to B" proposition.
Alternatively, Scorsese should have added to the plot a more plausible excuse for stopping along in Arizona, for example car trouble costing money and time to fix so the need to get a job, etc...

reply

I know what you mean! Even in 1974, the Interstate system was not exactly 2 lane roads all over the country and you could have easily made a trip from Soccoro to Phoenix in 1 day, probably some 300 miles. Yet this movie is making it like they're traveling all across America!

Yeah, if I was Alice, I would have just taken the trip, stopped in Phoenix or Yuma overnight, then gone to her parents house in Monterrey and stayed there until I could have got on my own two feet!

reply

I never got that either, and may have posted a similar thread previously. It seems too short a distance for the trek they made it out to be.

The fact that Alice stopped in some town to earn money as a singer made it appear ever more protracted. What was she going to do when she had enough money, just quit the singing job? Instead of the singing job, she could had gotten a waitressing job in that town instead of knocking on doors all day looking for a singing job.

reply

I've seen this movie 20 times and I never noticed this. It's just too entertaining and absorbing to think about, at least to me.

reply