Isn't this movie a little strange?


Okay, to summarize:

--The opening is done with 40's music, a beautiful script for the credits and the childhood scenes are in a deep red color, a la Gone With the Wind. Why?
--Next scene is in a craphole town in New Mexico, an uncommunicative blue-collar couple with a bratty son blasting Mott the Hoople on his record player
--After a fallout with the bratty son in the beginning, a scene with Alice shopping at the Utotem and her car being loaded with groceries. What was the point of that scene?
--Jodie Foster is a 12 year old tomboy offering Tommy to get wasted on ripple and keeps uttering the word "weird"
--And on top of all that, it's a more realistic version of Mel's Diner! In this one, Alice is a simple Southwestern blue-collar housewife, Tommy is a little turd, plain and simple, Flo is a sassy, no-nonsense rig camp type of woman, Vera is a klutzy and relatively dark-natured woman, and Mel is a gruff, but jovial diner owner. In the TV show, Alice is a Jewish former housewife from New Jersey, Tommy is a typical, but likable teen, Flo is a sassy, but comical and very likable clown, Vera is a klutzy, wound up, but sweet and innocent woman, and Mel is a gruff and cranky diner owner that's only jovial when things go well. Customers are all over the place in this one and the TV show there's no more than a dozen at any time

reply

This post makes my head hurt.

reply

This post helps my bowel movement.

no i am db

reply


you know...describing something doesn't explain why it's weird.

reply

It has what I would call an "Indie" realistic feel to it, with, interestingly, Scorsese at the helm. Maybe it WAS an Indie film? Not sure. There were a bunch of films at the time with an unusual/everyday feel to them: McCabe and Mrs. Miller fits in this category for me. I agree - I see no reason in that grocery scene. Then again, I see no reason in a lot of the scenes. It seems really dated to me now.

reply

[deleted]

The grocery scene was there to show how far Alice and Donald had grown apart. For her to tell the grocer that she was buying meat to get her husband going let's us know it's a bigger problem than the one bedroom scene showed.

reply

What I don't understand is how you can even mention that horrible sitcom "Alice" and this movie in the same breath. Yeah, the sitcom stole the names but that doesn't protect the innocent.

As far as some of your other puzzlements...just use your imagination..
The beginning theme is surrealistic and the wizard of oz type surroundings empathizes the magic of the rose colored dreams of childhood...closely followed by the dull tedium of adulthood and reality and grocery store shopping.

reply

I don't think that scene was there to show the tedium of adult life, but rather a life devoid of sex which Alice equates with intimacy. She isn't shown walking around mindlessly but telling the grocer her reason for buying so much meat.

reply

I wouldn't say the film is strange by any stretch. It's just a film about oakies.

reply

It was a movie about a woman and her kid. That's all. There wasn't a damn thing weird about it, and they weren't "oakies."

reply

The opening scene reminded me so much of The Wizard of Oz and then later I saw in the trivia section that was exactly what Scorsese was going for.

And yes the movie is strange, quirky I'd say, but in a good way. I liked its quirkiness.

Poorly Lived and Poorly Died, Poorly Buried and No One Cried

reply

Weird... definitely weird.

TV: http://ihatemydvr.blogspot.com
LOST:http://eyemsick.blogspot.com

reply