MovieChat Forums > Westworld (1973) Discussion > Guns don't kill people, but bladed weapo...

Guns don't kill people, but bladed weapons sure can!!!


It's easy for them to protect guests from harming other guests when using a firearm, but what is to stop a guest from killing another guest using a knife, or a sword?

They never quite explained how, if a guest doesn't know who's real, and who's a robot, they prevent them from killing each other by mistake using a bladed weapon, or by any other means.

Just another kink to work out in the reboot, I suppose.

reply

Yes, I was also expecting the human sheriff to be hit in the face during the fist fight in the saloon.. there was so much buildup and then nothing happened... haha

reply

The movie falls apart when you start questioning like this.
Thankfully, it is so incredibly entertaining, I forgive it a few lapses in logic.

The reboot is going to have to fix alot of this nonsense, if it wants to go all po faced on us!

reply

Well it didn't!
They never explained how can a bullet kill a robot and not even harm a human!
In some scenes of the TV show bullets can push a man while in other they fell nothing!
So its the same in the HBO WestWorld cause knifes, rocks, or other sharp and heavy objects can kill a person in the park!

reply

Actually, the movie does explain how it's possible: the guns have sensors that detect heat. If the weapon is pointed at something warm such as a human, it won't fire, but if it's pointed at something cold such as a robot, it will fire.

I have no enemies, but am intensely disliked by my friends.

reply

Well the HBO series never explaines how it's possible for a robot to get his head blown off and when a human is hit with a bullet he feels almost nothing!

Some say that the robots in the HBO series aren't really injured by the bullets and that they are programmed to react in that manner but it's clear that they are penetrated and damaged otherwise whats the point to repair them if they're not damaged!

Since the bullets in the HBO series fire at humans maybe they are made of some kind of specially designed rubber, plastic or foam that can penetrate the synthetic skin of the robots but can't get through the human skin

reply

Yeah, the series is a bit strange when it comes to bullets... the Man in Black, for example, is shown being shot multiple times by Teddy in the first episode. We can see impacts on his clothes, but he is clearly uninjured. In a later episode, Teddy starts firing a gatling gun, and we can see the bullets not only killing hosts, but also impacting inanimate objects such as tents, the ground, and especially a cart with some kind of barrels that explode. So in the show, some kind of projectile is actually fired, but it just hasn't been explained how it doesn't affect humans.

I have no enemies, but am intensely disliked by my friends.

reply

Yeah, the series is a bit strange when it comes to bullets... the Man in Black, for example, is shown being shot multiple times by Teddy in the first episode. We can see impacts on his clothes, but he is clearly uninjured. In a later episode, Teddy starts firing a gatling gun, and we can see the bullets not only killing hosts, but also impacting inanimate objects such as tents, the ground, and especially a cart with some kind of barrels that explode. So in the show, some kind of projectile is actually fired, but it just hasn't been explained how it doesn't affect humans.



I thought that the guns were without real bullets either way and that the robots were those that reacted when supposedly were shot. What I mean is that the robots bled either way somewhere on their bodies detecting some how if the gun was pointing on them.
In the end of the day who said that the guests of an amusement park of such kind, would knew how to shot at all and successfully hit any of their target ( enemies- whatever). They probably wouldn't so the owners of the park would had to find a way to satisfy them by making the robots look shot no matter what.

The problem with the swords and other similar weapons would be solved by allowing only a certain small number of guests belonging on the same group of visitors to get into the two other worlds. This would solve the problem of who is who.

reply

I was watching the TV show earlier today and had the same thought, and it applies even moreso to the movie. The firearms in Westworld can't harm humans, but those aren't the only weapons available; obviously, Medieval World and Roman World would use many bladed or blunt weapons, such as swords/knives/maces, and also more primitive projectile weapons such as bows/crossbows. Also, what about poison? In the movie, the "queen" was a guest in Medieval World and was seen dead on her throne with no apparent injuries (as was the Black Knight, who was a host, so I'm not quite sure about that). What if someone tried to poison the queen, not knowing she was a real person?

There are many loopholes, but I guess we just have to pretend that somehow the park has covered their bases and can prevent injuries from happening. You saw how Alan Oppenheimer's character reacted to a guest getting a simple snake bite ("this is inexcusable!"), so obviously nothing like that had happened in the past.

I have no enemies, but am intensely disliked by my friends.

reply

The movie is moronic. It's the exact type of science fiction written by someone wanting to pander to the type of person who back in caveman days would've regarded fire as a form of witchcraft.

reply

lol exactly

reply