MovieChat Forums > Walking Tall (1973) Discussion > Do you think he was right?

Do you think he was right?


Do you think Buford made the right choice in his actions as sheriff?

reply

Mmm, I don't remember many specifics about his Sheriff antics. But I did think it kinda dumb that he caused trouble in the beginning at the gambling joint. Unless maybe the game was rigged? Otherwise, he knew full well what his buddy would use the 50 for and only had himself to blame.

reply

Yes he was. If you played fair with him he played fair you.

reply

Do you think Buford made the right choice in his actions as sheriff?

IMO as a retired cop, the 1973 Hollywood version showed some accurate points. Imagine being elected as a tax collector and not knowing anything about accounting. Mr. Pusser was elected Sheriff and had no law enforcement experience. This became evident early on when his first big case was thrown out. The judge correctly cited the Constitution and how he had trespassed on private property without a warrant.

Even when this took place in the 60's, things such as the Miranda decision were in effect, although unless he questioned the people arrested that point cited by the judge was not a factor.

As for the revenge/other parts, I'd say he was generally justified. It was a different time, so we can't properly apply modern life to life back then.

He had some lines that were very good, such as when he first addressed the deputies and told them to treat everyone equally, and later with the guy from Nashville that the law of the land should not be for sale. If those (or something similar) actually took place, then again IMO he was a great Sheriff.

Ignoring politics doesn't mean politics will ignore you.
-Pericles paraphrased in <100 characters

reply

I lived in the Dixie Mafia part of Mississippi and the one thing I do know is a guy like him wouldn't have any association with any 2022 MAGA January 6ers.
He was actually patriotic.
He would have taken a big stick to those terrorist

reply

We need more like him today!

reply