While I don't condone Critchit's treatment of his wife (Critchit being the neat-freak's name,) I can certainly understand where he was coming from. He was used to everything being in a certain place so he could easily find everything and she kept moving things around. His basement workplace was a very special, important place for him, and then she messed it up. (Accidentally, of course, but still.) He did complement her earlier when she cleaned up the house and filled the kitchen shelf. The night before he'd volunteered to cook dinner, meaning he wasn't the kind of guy who expected his wife to slave in the kitchen every single night. And when he sees the mess in his workplace, this is after he's explained to her what an important place it is to him. Maybe he didn't need to flip out the way he did, but you have to understand he was narotic and facing a situation that would bother anyone. I'd like to have seen what would have happened later on if she hadn't killed him, after he'd had a chance to calm down.
In short, I feel that Critchit, like Ralph Jason, the guy whose wife makes a wish that leads to his death in the one story from the TALES FROM THE CRYPT film, did not deserve to go to hell (or limbo, or wherever). He was the one main character I really felt bad for.
reply
share