The constant cigarette smoking schtick was not a plus
Despite a few negatives, I generally liked Gould's portrayal of Philip Marlowe - yes, I understand it was supposed to be some "updated" interpretation of the character or something along those lines. But the excessive cigarette smoking done by Marlowe was too forced and too much of a distraction. And I'm not saying this because I'm against smoking, in fact I take a puff now and again myself, but it was just that the imagery was too forced and obvious, making the whole thing visually clumsy throughout.
Same as the reaction I had to Bill Murray's character and his constant cigarette schtick in "Rushmore."