Who Else Could Have Played Molly?
When "Charley Varrick" went into production in late 1972, it had just one major star attached: Walter Matthau as Charley Varrick, the anti-hero.
But when "Charley Varrick" came out in October of 1973, it now had TWO stars: Walter Matthau and Joe Don Baker.
Matthau still got the only "over-the-title" billing but in the spring, summer and fall of 1973, Joe Don Baker had become a star of sorts with the outta-nowhere B-movie action thriller, "Walking Tall," in which Baker played real-life hero sheriff Buford Pusser, an ex-wrestler who used a baseball-bat like club to bust Southern Mafia heads.
I'm assuming "Charley Varrick" director Don Siegel or some casting director at Universal saw "Walking Tall" and thus Joe Don Baker got the role.
But sometimes I wonder: if Baker wasn't quite so hot then(and he had NOT been hot in recent years prior to "Walking Tall")...who might have played Molly?
I'm afraid my first thoughts are with older men of the time, "big men" of the time: George Kennedy and Richard Boone. Both men specialized in a certain "big guy menace" and both guys(especially Boone) knew how to play baddies with smiling humor.
If Universal had been willing to pop for a star of Matthau's caliber, perhaps Robert Mitchum or Lee Marvin would have fit the bill. But Marvin was a bigger star than Matthau.
And still I think I'm thinking too "old" for what Molly ended up being with Joe Don Baker in the part.
One younger name that comes to mind is: Bo Swenson. He was a huge, strapping guy who eventually played Baker's old part of Buford Pusser in one of the "Walking Tall" sequels.
Any other candidates from 1972 or 1973 to play Molly?
On the other hand...Joe Don was perfect. Casting makes a movie, and Joe Don Baker's casting was perfect for Charley Varrick.