MovieChat Forums > The Godfather (1972) Discussion > "Leave the gun" filmed in wrong location...

"Leave the gun" filmed in wrong location. Statue of Liberty is backwards


In the "Leave the gun. Take the cannolis" scene, they are on their way back to the mall from looking for places in Manhattan for the button men to go to the mattresses. This is shown both in the movie itself, as they're driving around Manhattan to do so, and then leave to drive out of town, and especially in "The Godfather Epic" version, where Clemenza explicitly says that when he spoke to Sonny, Sonny told them to get back to the mall.

The mall is supposed to be in Long Beach, on Long Island. As a Long Island boy, I know this because of the toll booths where Sonny is killed. But also see this:

http://godfather.wikia.com/wiki/Corleone_mall

However, when Clemenza gets out to take a leak among the reeds, the Statue of Liberty is in the background. And she's facing the wrong way. The Statue of Liberty faces east, towards Long Island. We see her back. That means, as Bruce Springsteen would no doubt sing, that Paulie is about to get stuck in the mud somewhere in the swamps of Jersey. That's one helluva detour from Manhattan to get to Long Beach.

Funny how this is the first time I ever noticed this in 40 years.




I want the doctor to take your picture so I can look at you from inside as well.

reply

Clearly the scene was filmed somewhere in the New Jersey Meadowlands area. I was always under the impression that they drove from NYC to New Jersey and that is where the scene was supposed to take place. I don't remember why I thought that, whether it is something in the book, the dialog in the movie, or I just assumed that because I recognized the location, I will pay more attention next time I watch it.

reply

Yup, that's just about exactly where it was filmed, before Jimmy Hoffa was buried underneath the old Giants Stadium. (heh, heh)

But there wouldn't be any reason for them to go to New Jersey. That would be the DiMeo family over there. Not Corleone territory.




I want the doctor to take your picture so I can look at you from inside as well.

reply

Well there was one reason.... to dispose of a body. Back in the 1940s I bet that car could have sat there for months or longer without being found.

reply

Oh, sure. But how do you convince Paulie to drive out there when there's no body in the car? "Hey, Paulie, take the Holland Tunnel and drive out to the Meadowlands, I gotta take a leak."




I want the doctor to take your picture so I can look at you from inside as well.

reply

Well I don't have any first (or second or third) hand information regarding the inner workings of the Mafia, but I'm gonna guess that when a Caporegime tells his a driver/body guard to drive somewhere he is not required to provide an explanation, But like I said it has always been my assumption that the scene was supposed to take place in NJ but I certainly could be wrong. Next time I watch the movie I am going to pay closer attention to the scenes leading up to Paulie's death.

reply

FROM THE BOOK

Clemenza said sourly to Gatto, “Damn that Sonny, he’s running scared. He’s already thinking of going to the mattresses. We have to find a place on the West Side. Paulie, you and Rocco gotta staff and supply it until the word comes down for the rest of the soldiers to use it. You know a good location?”

As he had expected, Gatto‘s eyes became greedily interested. Paulie had swallowed the bait and because he was thinking how much the information was worth to Sollozzo, he was forgetting to think about whether he was in danger. Also, Lampone was acting his part perfectly, staring out the window in a disinterested, relaxed way. Clemenza congratulated himself on his choice.

Gatto shrugged. “I’d have to think about it,” he said.

Clemenza grunted. “Drive while you think, I want to get to New York today.

Paulie was an expert driver and traffic going into the city was light at this time in the afternoon, so the early winter darkness was just beginning to fall when they arrived. There was no small talk in the car.

Clemenza directed Paulie to drive up to the Washington Heights section. He checked a few apartment buildings and told him to park near Arthur Avenue and wait. He also left Rocco Lampone in the car. He went into the Vera Mario Restaurant and had a light dinner of veal and salad, nodding his hellos to some acquaintances. After an hour had gone by he walked the several blocks to where the car was parked and entered it.

Gatto and Lampone were still waiting. *beep* Clemenza said, “they want us back in Long Beach. They got some other job for us now. Sonny says we can let this one go until later. Rocco, you live in the city, can we drop you off?”

Rocco said quietly, “I have my car out at your place and my old lady needs it first thing in the morning.”

“That’s right,” Clemenza said. “Then you have to come back with us, after all.”

Again on the ride back to Long Beach nothing was said. On the stretch of road that led into the city, Clemenza said suddenly, “Paulie, pull over, I gotta take a leak.”

From working together so long, Gatto knew the fat caporegime had a weak bladder. He had often made such a request. Gatto pulled the car off the highway onto the soft earth that led to the swamp. Clemenza climbed out of the car and took a few steps into the bushes. He actually relieved himself. Then as he opened the door to get back into the car he took a quick look up and down the highway. There were no lights, the road was completely dark. “Go ahead,” Clemenza said. A second later the interior of the car reverberated with the report of a gun. Paulie Gatto seemed to jump forward, his body flinging against the steering wheel and then slumping over to the seat.

Clemenza had stepped back hastily to avoid being hit with fragments of skull bone and blood. Rocco Lampone scrambled out of the back seat. He still held the gun and he threw it into the swamp. He and Clemenza walked hastily to a car parked nearby and got in. Lampone reached underneath the seat and found the key that had been left for them. He started the car and drove Clemenza to his home.

Then instead of going back by the same route, he took the Jones Beach Causeway right on through to the town of Merrick and onto the Meadowbrook Parkway until he reached the Northern State Parkway. He rode that to the Long Island Expressway and then continued on to the Whitestone Bridge and through the Bronx to his home in Manhattan.

Scariest words in English: We’re from the federal government and we’re here to help. R. Reagan

reply

Good catch!

reply

Yep, it's definitely filmed from the Jersey meadowlands.

"Smokey, this is not 'Nam, this is bowling. There are rules. "
-Walter Sobchak

reply