MovieChat Forums > Silent Running (1972) Discussion > Awesome movie except the soundtrack

Awesome movie except the soundtrack


I realize it was the early 1970s, so that whole late 60s, hippie folk thing was still big, but the soundtrack was the only part of this movie I couldn't take. It was way too sappy and over-the-top for what was otherwise a great movie. It just seemed more appropriate for some movie about Woodstock or something. The movie IMO could've been way better and more serious if they didn't use that ridiculous music. I just kept waiting for hippies to pop out of the trees on the ship wearing flower power t-shirts. That is why 2001: A Space Odyssey's soundtrack holds up way better; classical music that is somewhat timeless, versus hippie folk stuff that only appealed to a mass audience in the late 60s and early 70s (despite the fact that less than 10% of people were actually hippies).

Anyway, just my thoughts. The soundtrack just seemed way too out of place and to me took away a little bit from what was otherwise a great film. It beat the audience over the heads with the environmentalist thing instead of being subtle in its message like I think movies with a message should be. In my opinion, if a movie is done artistically enough, you shouldn't need to beat the audience over the head with the message.

reply

I didn't mind the score, it was pretty good, it was the soft-pop songs and lyrics (o, child of the forest, plant the seeds of wisdom etc.) that made me cringe


-----
Wednesday has been cancelled due to a scheduling error
-----

reply

Yeah the lyrics made me cringe constantly.

reply

Couldn't agree more. I have no idea why Joan Baez was popular. Other folk singers from the era I understand- Dylan, Simon and Garfunkel, Peter Paul and Mary, Pete Seeger, and so on. But Baez is just awful. Moanful, melodramatic, crap.

If you're a religion, you can have a canon. If you're a scifi franchise, get over yourself.

reply

[deleted]

I wonder if they could rerelease this with a new sound track? I think it would help and bring this movie back to where more people would watch it.

reply

Totally agree! If they just got rid of the flower power b.s. it would be great.

reply

You know, I like some Folk music, but Joan Baez was just pretentious as hell!

reply

The band 65daysofstatic were asked to re-write the soundtrack and perform it live for a film festival a couple of years ago, and they are performing it again at Convergence Festival in London on 27th April.

There's a live recording synced with the film on youtube (search "65 vs Silent Running"). It's not great quality, and may not be to your taste, but it'll give you an idea what their soundtrack is like.

reply

Hey thanks for letting me know about this. Cheers!

reply

[deleted]

Bull. The score was gorgeous and I wish "PDQ Bach" had made more of them. Agreed, however, that it could have done without Baez. You win some, you lose some.

reply

Yeah most of it was good. I should have clarified my subject line: Awesome movie except for the Baez music. ;)

reply

Yeah most of it was good. I should have clarified my subject line: Awesome movie except for the Baez music. - hexedd

That's fine--except that it wasn't "Baez music." Joan Baez sang the two songs, "Silent Running" and "Rejoice in the Sun," but both were written by Peter Schickele (AKA PDQ Bach) and Diane Lampert.

------------------
"We hear very little, and we understand even less." - Refugee in Casablanca

reply

" Anyway, just my thoughts. The soundtrack just seemed way too out of place and to me took away a little bit from what was otherwise a great film. "

I chuckle to myself because I'd guess that 40 years from today fans will watch good movies from our era and think "The soundtrack just seemed way too out of place and to me took away a little bit from what was otherwise a great film."

TxMike
Make a choice, to take a chance, to make a difference.

reply

Fair enough. But that's why I'm a big fan of movies like 2001: A Space Odyssey that use classical music, since it seems to have a more timeless quality, and makes the soundtrack seem like it still "fits", even more than 40 years later.

reply

Schikele's soundtrack and Baez's songs were completely appropriate to the film. They're only "date" if one deliberately associates the film with the hippy eco-ethic, which is an arbitrary, unnecessary and pointless thing to do. The original score was fresh, crisp and alternately pleasingly melodic and jarringly atonal. A little gem of a score.

reply

Schikele's soundtrack and Baez's songs were completely appropriate to the film. They're only "date" if one deliberately associates the film with the hippy eco-ethic, which is an arbitrary, unnecessary and pointless thing to do. The original score was fresh, crisp and alternately pleasingly melodic and jarringly atonal. A little gem of a score.


Amen.

reply