MovieChat Forums > Silent Running (1972) Discussion > Joan Baez: Like A Nail In My Forehead

Joan Baez: Like A Nail In My Forehead


I love this movie. I actually welled up with tears at the end when I saw it many years ago. And then? Joan Baez starting CATERWALLING. And ruined EVERYTHING.

Her faux-operatic bellowing is so awful, it makes me not want to watch it again.

The odd thing is that I -love- the soundtrack by Peter Schickele and I feel guilty in writing the above because I know he looooooooves her singing.

reply

I think it really dates the film and it is generally intolerable (just as I found Baez intolerable back then). Luckily the movie is great so I can forgive it.


I don’t need you to tell me how good my coffee is.. 
.

reply

You hit the nail on the head. The really sad part (for me) is that Trumbull's miniatures (in 2001 and here) have a timeless quality. If I could erase -her- it wouldn't feel dated at all.

reply

the soundtrack by Peter Schickele


When I saw this movie, I was surprised to see P.D.Q. Bach in the credits. I've always liked Schickele's classical music parodies, I had no idea he also did film scores.

But you're right, Baez's wailing is annoying. To me, it was the final nail in the coffin of what was a mostly disappointing movie regardless, even though I usually enjoy Bruce Dern's performances.

reply

He was the string arranger on many of her albums. He is also well known as a composer of 'serious' music.

And he is -crazy- about her voice. He has been a champion of old time 'Americana' folk music since forever. I believe he once said that her voice is like the perfect blend of operatic and folk. Which (for me) is like saying the perfect blend of cyanide and strychnine.


Why? I came into this game for the action, the excitement... Listen, kid, we're all in it together.

reply

LOL! I can totally see why you would feel that way but I Absolutely LOVE the soundtrack! Soooo dated but it's adorable, this movie is so strange because it's actually really adorable but when you look at the concept it's really frightening !!!

reply