MovieChat Forums > Silent Running (1972) Discussion > This final line was sometimes missing (s...

This final line was sometimes missing (spoiler)


[Lowell, to Huey, as he prepares to blow up the ship] "You know, when I was a kid, I put a note into a bottle and it had my name and address on it. And then I threw the bottle into the ocean. And I never knew if anybody ever found it."

That line was in it when I first saw SR on television in the 70s, but was missing from the mid-80s VHS release. Does the DVD release have it?

When I saw that it was missing from the VHS release, I guessed that Trumbull had later decided to remove it because Earth, as it was described throughout the movie, may have been so transformed that oceans, at least as we know them, no longer existed.

The ending works with or without it (doesn't take a genius to see the "bottle in the ocean" symbolism), but I had long wondered why it was removed.

reply

I haven't seen the DVD version, but I did see the movie recently on Movieplex (an Encore/Starz channel) and the "message in a bottle" line was still there at the end.


dictionary.com and spellcheck.com.
Don't post without it!

reply

It is a part of the DVD.



I disagree with you, but I'm pretty sure you're not Hitler.
- Jon Stewart

reply

I wonder if it had been edited out at one time because it was setting up for the final scene that they didn't end up filming where the dome would later be found by aliens.

reply

I just saw the film with that line included and it wouldn't seem to make sense that it would be removed for that reason; Lowell already has memories of forests (presumably now gone), and could just as easily have memories of oceans - but frankly the oceans probably still exist.

reply

The line in question was removed due to a suit brought by the Flat Earth Society. It was later reinstated after the suit was overturned on appeal.

We have a special for today only on Brooklyn bridges, how many may I put you down for?

reply