MovieChat Forums > Klute (1971) Discussion > Barbra Streisand for the role of Bree?! ...

Barbra Streisand for the role of Bree?! I think NOT!


Barbra Streisand turned down the role of Bree Daniels, which Jane Fonda eventually played.

You'll find that little nugget in the Trivia section, and I would love to know who submitted it and what his or her source is because it does not compute.

Years and years ago I bought the book “The Films of Jane Fonda” by George Haddad-Garcia and I have been well aware for over a quarter of a century that Jane Fonda was the only actress ever considered for the part.

The following excerpt is taken straight from the book:

>In typical method style, Fonda prepared for Klute by speaking with high-class call girls in Manhattan, discussing their work and lifestyles. She didn’t have to do very extensive research, however, for the role was painstakingly written beforehand.

The whole project was unorthodox, risky, and highly challenging. Director-producer Alan J. Pakula admitted, “It’s a film I would not have done without Jane. I had met her a long time before, but I never really talked in any depth with her until a couple of weeks before I was sent the screenplay …

But I met Jane, and we talked for several hours about a lot of things – about women in our society, about sexuality in our society. It was just a wonderful, freewheeling discussion. I came out of it thinking, ‘I d love to work with that woman.’ About two weeks later the Klute script was sent to me, and I called her immediately.”

After she got the script Fonda was unsure about her feelings; one insider said she wasn’t eager to get back to playing ‘easy women’ after her excellent, image-breaking work in Horses. Pakula recalled, “She said, ‘I don’t really know what I feel about it.’ We talked for a half hour; she had an interviewer waiting and she had to get rid of me. She said, ‘Look, do you really want to do it?’ I said yes. She said, ‘Okay, I’ll do it’. Out of such little statements things get made”.<

Source: “The Films of Jane Fonda” by George Haddad-Garcia (Citadel Press, 1981, ISBN 0-8065-0752-7), pp. 157-158.

Note: The film title Horses was the popular abbreviation for They Shoot Horses, Don't They?.

reply

I've read in a Julie Christie bio she was offered the part too. Maybe there were other people attached before Pakula? Maybe a couple of big name stars were offered it first before a director came on board. I guess just because she was Pakula's choice doesn't mean she was the only actress to be offered the part. I'm glad he got his way though.

reply

This comes as a bit of a shock but, yes, who knows - maybe the script landed in other hands before it was passed on to Pakula.

Still, I find it strange that there was no mention of either Streisand or Christie in the Jane Fonda bio since these were two very fashionable names at the time and winning out over them would have earned Jane extra kudos.

But I fully agree with you. Jane Fonda was the best choice. Thanks for the feedback.

reply

It's possible the studio tried to lure Streisand and Christie at the time with choice of director. It was a great star vehicle for an actress. I read somewhere else that both Faye Dunaway and Shirley MacLaine were offered the part too. I'm not sure what Fonda's stock was like at the time, but it was a similar time to all the "Hanoi Jane" business so I don't imagine she was first choice for any producer back then. She most likely only got the role because they declined. If they had accepted it probably wouldn't have been directed by Pakula, or if it had he would have had to toe the line. Fonda may not have mentioned it because she might not have known for sure who was offered the role - it's pretty obvious she was Pakula's first choice and it really is Pakula's film. Ultimately it's a brilliant performance, by a brilliant actress in a brilliant film. As good as the other actresses are I don't quite see them in the role - at least not the way Fonda played it - and I can't imagine the character any other way now.

reply

You posters sure have some interesting info on the subject. I'm more curious than doubtful now (hence the deletion of "I think not" in the subject line).

As for Jane's stock at the time, her political drive had apparently just begun to manifest itself during the filming of Klute.

Taken from the same book I quoted in my first posting ... and funnily enough the very next paragraph:

>By the time the movie started shooting, Pakula found “Jane had changed considerably. She had become firmly politicized, and she came to the set with this great passion – about everything, really – and I was concerned that her mind was not going to be on the film. She was very involved in so many causes. But she has this extraordinary kind of concentration. She can … make endless phone calls … and seem to be totally uninterested in the film. But when you say, ‘We’re ready for you, Jane,’ she says, ‘All right, give me a few minutes.’ She just stands quietly for three minutes and concentrates, and then she’s totally and completely in the film, and nothing else exists. And when the scene is right … she goes right back to the phone, and that other world is total. It’s a gift good actors have; she has it to an extraordinary degree.”<

There’s more if anyone is interested:

>Klute was Fonda’s first film since her trip to India, with its intensely affecting aftermath. For the first time, her acting chores were mixed with political concerns, and it was on the set of Klute that she became known as the Mad Caller. She offered, “A year ago, for me to pick up the phone and call practically anyone except the people I was really intimate with was a trauma. I hated the telephone. I never answered the phone; Vadim always answered … Now I must make forty calls a day to people I don’t even know … asking them all for favors, for money. I sometimes think, ‘What am I dong? It’s impossible that someone has changed this much!’”<

I’m actually wondering now if this classic shot is of Fonda making one of those calls between takes on the set of Klute since it was obviously not from any scene in the film:

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_WV-Hm8p1rQU/SxLkloceI1I/AAAAAAAAA5c/8CNRgnsr 6a4/s1600/klute.jpg

I used to think it was purely a publicity shot - which it obviously ended up being - but I'm thinking it may have been the result of someone snapping a photo of The Mad Caller and liking it enough to have it incorporated into the film's promo material due to its call + girl theme. . I've seen the original image with the "Library" sign in the background. I think the idea of using it in the poster must have come along later.








reply

[deleted]

Miss Streisand jokes with Jane and always says to her "If it weren't for me you wouldn't have a career" since she turned down Klute, They Shoot Horses... and another film I can't seem to think of

I should've left my phone @ home cause this is a Dizastah!

reply

Wow! Thanks for contributing this. I also found other material supporting this: http://thisdistractedglobe.com/2008/04/21/klute-1971-2/

Well, I'm sold!

reply

I read about Streisand being offered the role of Bree in a biography about her, released about 8 years ago (?)

Streisand was a HUGE star at the time, in both the world of films, TV and music. Producers thought they were really covering their bases in trying to get her.

If she got it, I wonder what her traditional song behind the opening credits would have been like?

"I walk these streets, just me and my cat
I wonder where...it is all at?
The phone rings...no one's there for me
Or else it's someone
Just putting the scares in me...

Oooooh OH OH LONELY TOWN
New Yawk is a LONELY TOWN....."


----------------------------------------------------------------------

PS: If you really want to hear something unbelievable but TRUE, Streisand was also offered the role of the mother in The Exorcist ( ! ? ! ? ! ? ) Try to picture THAT one for a minute!!
.

reply

LMAO (the song). Dear God, makes you wonder what people were thinking at the time (and 'Exorcist', too?). This film would have been destroyed with anyone but Jane (let alone Barbra). The only other actress mentioned for the part that I could possibly see in it is Julie Christie, for some reason. But, Jane is one of the handful of reasons of why this film is as famous now.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

would be interesting to see babs in this, she wouldve been decent i think, whe was a good actress in her day but fonda owns this role

reply

I think Streisand is a better actress than what many give her credit for and for the reasons suggested on here, her being offered the role was a non-brainer. But Fonda really is stunning as Bree and nobody could have been better, though Dunaway (who Fonda originally suggested) would have come close.

reply

[deleted]