MovieChat Forums > Klute (1971) Discussion > Fonda well deserved the Oscar

Fonda well deserved the Oscar


Jane Fonda is so amazingly perfect in this role a spot on performance all around but I would have to say my favorite scene is near the end when she is listening to the tape of her girlfriend and its a side profile of her face and she is crying and I mean really crying tears running down dropping off the end of her nose I remember being so incredibly moved the first time I saw it.

Spica in Virgo,a June sky

reply

Watching it again last night. It is a great performance, but it's the only role that Fonda really shines in, probably because she's such a cold actress to begin with, the way Bree herself is cold -- so when she breaks down in the dress factory, it's especially powerful.


"Follow those who seek the truth. Avoid those who find it."

reply

[deleted]

It's often hard to separate Jane the personality from Jane the actress, but she totally became the characters in "Klute" and "They Shoot Horses, Don't They?" These are thoughtful, gritty performances that are too often ignored when people focus on her activism.

It's too bad that she was merely "good" in many of her later roles, but she set the bar quite high early in her career. And "Monster in Law" was just plain embarrassing, in my book!

reply

This may not make me particularly "cinematically cultured" but i thought she was freaking hilarious in Monster-in-Law.

reply

Oh, that's OK. There are a lot of films I love that other people hate. But I would have liked "Monster in Law" more if they didn't show the best scenes already in the previews.

reply

troy--I completely agree--her performances in those 2 pictures are astonishing. I think her relationship with Hayden must've released something in her--a freedom to rebel, unshackle herself from the repressiveness of her cold, austere father. In both performances, she's alive every moment. She understands and projects both the characters' iron toughness and vulnerability perfectly. They're amazing accomplishments. Nothing else she did achieved that level of brilliance, and a number of her efforts are undistinguished. But her Gloria and Bree are two of the finest performances you'll see on film.

reply

One of Jane's finest performances..she earned her Oscar as well as for Coming Home..watch her in this one making love to Jon Voigt, a paraplegic...she earned her Oscar for this role as well!

So add Sally Hyde to the list with Gloria Beatty and Bree Daniels.



"Oh my God! Where did that orchestra come from??"..

reply

i read somewhere that the role was originally offered to...you may want to sit down...barbara streisand. gross!!! imagine barbara streisand in that shrink-fonda improv scene! (i shudder)

i once fought an elephant in my pajamas, how it got in my pajamas i don't know.

reply

"i read somewhere that the role was originally offered to...you may want to sit down...barbara streisand. gross!!! imagine barbara streisand in that shrink-fonda improv scene! (i shudder) "

Streisand says she tells Jane Fonda all the time if it hadn't been for her she wouldn't have a career because she turned down Klute, Julia and They Shoot Horses, Don't They? Streisand also says she's kinda sad she turned down Julia because Lillian Hellman said to her, "YOU should've played me"

reply

And Jane Fonda also turned down Bonnie and Clyde and The Exorcist BTW. Can you imagine Streisand as Bree Daniels or Gloria Beatty--please.

reply

I was a bit sad when I heard Jane turned down The Exorcist but she says she doesn't like scary movies. Jane has turned down A LOT of films, sadly

reply

Yes, Streisand turned down the role and Fonda got the Oscar. But I can't see Fonda doing Funny Girl, can you? Among Pauline Kael's favorites was Jane Fonda and Barbra Streisand.
Both wonderful actresses in the right vehicles..

"Oh my God! Where did that orchestra come from??"..

reply

Jane Fonda winning for Klute in 1971 was one of the most deserved Best Actress wins in Oscar history. Bree Daniels is such a great character. Fonda was astonishing and painful to watch, in a good way. She simply blew me away.

reply

[deleted]

I used to "work out" to them as well.

reply

Yes, not just tears but snot. Amazing scene, in a long unbroken take.

--------
See a list of my favourite films here: http://www.flickchart.com/slackerinc

reply

[deleted]

Agreed she is brilliant in this film.

It is my business to protect your majesty.... against all things.

reply

[deleted]