MovieChat Forums > Get Carter (1971) Discussion > The Pornography/Hypocrisy Angle in "Get ...

The Pornography/Hypocrisy Angle in "Get Carter" (SPOILERS)


The street-level savagery of Get Carter has made the film a classic over the years. That and its very realistic Newcastle settings and Michael Caine's ultra-cool sociopathic performance.

But matters come to a head for the movie in that breakthrough scene in which Carter, lying in bed after a coital romp with a Newcastle "hooker in residence"(likely in the employ of local crime bosses to entertain themselves AND visitors, and thus not always requiring a paid trick) and plays the porno film on a projector in the bedroom.

The hooker's taking a bath as Carter watches the crummy, ultra-low budget "local production"(I guess we'd call it "amateur porn" today) ..and Carter suddenly sees his teenage niece appear on screen.

The cuts are away from the porn and to Carter's face, with his sociopathic savagery now undercut by...tears. Tears of family pain. Tears of disgust with the underbelly of his chosen profession(organized crime.) Tears of disgust with himself.

And that disgust turns to rage. First up for brutal payback: the hooker in the bathtub.

Others will pay as the film goes on from this point. Including Carter himself.

But the scene haunts, to this day, because: as heartbroken and disgusted as Carter is to see his own niece starring in a porno...did he ever care this much about all the OTHER girls exploited that way?

Indeed, "Get Carter" opens with Carter and some British crime bosses WATCHING porno...slides , not film (which is interestingly dated) and Carter doesn't much care about THOSE women.

On the other , other hand, as I recall , Carter doesn't choose to actually watch the porn with his bosses. He is looking out the window, concentrating on other things.

"Get Carter" makes a point, as it goes along, of indicating that in the male-centered British gangster world of 1971, the men are killers and crooks...but the women(beauties all) are to be sexual objects, bought and paid for by their male masters, one way or the other. This extends to the porn actresses, the hooker types in Newcastle(there are two and Carter harms them both), and to the London gangster's girlfriend(Britt Ekland) with whom Carter is carrying on an affair.

That Carter's young niece would be added to this sexual stable may enrage him to murder but...its just a part of the business really, isn't it?

To this day.

reply

I agree, the implication throughout is that Doreen is HIS daughter.

Keith- recovering on the bed after a beating, even screams this out loud to an uncaring, exiting Carter.

reply

Yep..its strongly suggested to the point of being "the truth."

Which only makes Carter's murderous rage and self-disgust more understandable....like when he knifes the guy near "the toilet." And when beating the guy and throwing him off the parking garage. Both times.. he references his niece.

reply

He does. Maybe he's still covering his own family secret in some misguided loyalty to his dead brother?

Maybe he is attoning for sleeping with his brother's wife, in his own deluded way?

reply


He does. Maybe he's still covering his own family secret in some misguided loyalty to his dead brother?

Maybe he is attoning for sleeping with his brother's wife, in his own deluded way

---

I would agree with both of those aspects.

Carter's a "bad man." A killer. As he says to a woman along the way, "I was always the villain in this family." But his initial investigations into his brother's killer are cold, "all-business," tough. Its only when he sees the porno with his "niece" that he goes utterly berserk. Viciously grabbing(if not beating) the naked woman he's just made love with, and throwing her in the trunk of her car(where she will die when the car is sunk in the bay). Killing men with a psychopathic rage and cruelty(he misleads the guy near the toilet that he won't kill him if he talks, then gets the info and says "you knew what I'd do, didn't you?" and stabs him.) And coldly killing one more woman(by overdose) after making her strip ALMOST naked(he needs her topless to suggest sexual goings on, but he doesn't make her get naked...its almost gallant before he kills her.)

And for Eric, he has "pure revenge" -- make the man forcibly drink whiskey as the man made his brother forcibly drink whisky -- an "eye for an eye."

What makes Get Carter so powerful in its third act is that Carter's sudden realization that he is in in a world that horribly exploits women is what finally "gets him." His niece. His daughter? Killing and thieving has never bothered him, but this does.

reply