same as the book?


is it true that the book got banned? did the book have the famous nude wrestling scene?....this info will help me in my english lit homework cheers!


'The appearance of law must be upheld, especially when it's being broken!'

reply

The movie - probably my third favourite movie of all time - is very faithful to the novel. The book did include the famous wrestling scene. DH Lawrence was gay so I think he understood the dynamics of a scene like that very well. I'm not sure whether or not the book was banned - I do know that it was extremely frowned upon when it first came out. It still remains shocking and gutsy, much like Lady Chatterley's Lover ( That book was banned ). Still, try to read the book and watch the movie. The movie has all the art, the book has all the profound writing.

reply

D.H. Lawrence gay? His main sexual interest seems to have been women, but I supposed that his main sexual interest was in sex.

reply

I doubt DH was gay, because I was reading a biography about him not two hours ago where his wife said that he was one of the most sexually potent men ever (or something like that). I don't think he would have been able to sex her so satisfyingly if he was gay.

Oh, and to the original poster: read DH's "Lady Chatterley's Lover". "Women in Love" was good (DH's second-best, of the four I read), but "Lady Chatterley's Lover" is uber amazing and absolutelyliciously wonderful. And, as an added bonus, it's DH's only sexually explicit novel.

Oh, and "Women in Love" did indeed face censorship. I think someone tried to get it banned in the US when it came out, but they failed, and everyone heard about it and wanted to read it, so DH Lawrence was moderately wealthy for the 1st time in his life.

"What is **nt?" --Lady Chatterley

reply

I doubt DH was gay, because I was reading a biography about him not two hours ago where his wife said that he was one of the most sexually potent men ever (or something like that). I don't think he would have been able to sex her so satisfyingly if he was gay.

What a ludicrously ignorant comment.

reply

He was entirely uncertain about his own sexuality. He was drawn to homosexuality and repulsed by it at the same time.

reply

I personally think that the movie and the book are completely different. I mean yeah the story line is the same, but it is way different and not as good. And there seemed to be nudity thrown into the movie just for the sake of having it.

reply

I agree, after i red the book i've actually noticed quite a few differences, inspite of the many voices which state ( justified up to a point) that the film renders the book faithfully, but i would add faithfully but with some liberties. To put it more precisely, in the book it is not Gerald's sister which marries in the beginning that eventually drowns, it is another sister and she drowns not toghtter with her husband but with a local doctor, in quite different circumstances: she actually drowns the doctor and then dies either by accident during the struggle that took place while choking him or by suicide. Secondly, in the book the drowning and the wrestling scene are placed at a fairly importnant distance between each other, unlike the film where one simply follows the other, but here i can partly understand Russell's intetion to connect these two in order to make the transition from the dead bodies to the living, energetic and sexually active bodies more dramatic, even the number of the protagonists these scenes being, on both occasions, two. Third, Gerald is described blond in the book, while Oliver Reed is dark-haired, fourth the winter holiday takes place in Innsbruck, not in Zermatt like in the film. Now i know thet a screenplay is allowed to have certain inaccuracies and that it might focus less on exact renditions of a book, i still don't know why Russell could overook this details, as i doubt that he wouldn't have the talent, the allround knowledge, the staff or the vision to get these detaills sorted out more accurately.

reply

[deleted]

It was never banned. The Rainbow was banned in the UK.

reply