What Music?


Can anyone identify the melody being played by Sherlock Holmes on his violin?

(OK, the answer might be on http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0000067/bio )

reply

My memory is it's just the main theme from the movie

reply

It was the Violin Concerto, op. 26, by Miklos Rozsa. So far as I know this concerto by one of the greatest of all film composers was not intended to be used for a film, but Wilder & Co. use it very well here.

reply

Actually I think it's Korngold's Concerto, which is on a CD with the Rosza Theme and Variations. It was, IIRC, commissioned by Jascha Heifitz, and predates the movie by at least 10-15 years, if not more.

I was watching this on cable yesterday and suddenly realized by the music sounded familiar.

reply

Hi paulhume;
No, it is definitely the Rozsa Violin Concerto Op. 24 second movement (lento cantabile.) Having also just seen the film on cable yesterday, and wondering about that lovely music, I went to Amazon and sampled the cuts from that CD you mentioned. The Korngold is similar, but no doubt the music in the film is the Rozsa. A CD that will soon be added to my collection, BTW!

reply

It is, in fact, Rózsa's Violin Concerto in D, Opus 24.

The concerto was, in fact, one of Wilder's primary motivations for writing the HOLMES (with I.A.L. Diamond) script in the first place (though he'd actually conceived of doing a Holmes musical in the 1950s, the script to be co-written with veteran screenwriter Harry Kurnitz). At a party, Wilder approached Rózsa, who'd scored several of the director's greatest films -- the under-appreciated FIVE GRAVES TO CAIRO, DOUBLE INDEMNITY and THE LOST WEEKEND, and asked for a replacement LP record copy of the concerto, as he'd worn out the one he had.

Intrigued, Rózsa asked Wilder why he'd been playing it so much that it needed replacing. Wilder replied that the work's second movement reminded him of Sherlock Holmes's addiction to cocaine, and he'd been listening to it to put him in the mood to work on a Holmes screenplay.

More than a decade later, when the film was finally about to go into production, Wilder had the producers (who are, parenthetically, relatives of mine) sign Rózsa to write the music, much of which would be adapted from the 1953 concerto (all three movements provided themes that were expanded and developed in the film score).

As it turned out THE PRIVATE LIFE OF SHERLOCK HOLMES was the only instance in which Rózsa adapted one of his concert works for the screen; he also never incorporated themes he wrote for film scores into concert pieces (though he did adapt several film scores into concert suites).

If you are sufficiently interested, there is a brand-new recording of the complete film score, one of its composer's masterpieces. It can be purchased here:

www.screenarchives.com/title_detail.cfm?ID=6676

reply

Bravo! Wonderfully specific information!

You are a conductor of light!

"...observation, deduction, and exact knowledge."

reply

There was another tune, when the girl appeared. La Folia by Vivaldi

reply

Corelli

reply

Just purchased a CD of the newly recorded complete score of this film, including outakes and optional versions, by Tadlow Music. Purchased mine at Intrada.com. Very nicely done and plentiful notes and pictures. Holmes and Watson live on...!
RSGRE

reply