MovieChat Forums > MASH (1970) Discussion > Question about Spearchucker

Question about Spearchucker


How in the world was he able to become a neurosurgeon AND a football star? As you know, in high school those who were on the teams had to skip classes so they weren't exactly the brightest candles on the cake, no offense intended.
Brain surgery isn't some one-day seminar, I think it takes at least 10 years to be fully certified. Spearchucker only appears to be about 30, maybe 27 at the least. So, how was he able to dedicate himself to the NFL, and join the 49ers AND get his phD in neurology??

reply

[deleted]

Were the requirements for becoming a neurosurgeon as rigorous in 1950 as they are now? Sure it's far fetched, but not impossible. By the time future Supreme Court Justice Byron White was 30, he had spent a year in Oxford as a Rhodes scholar, led the NFL in rushing (twice), graduated from Yale Law School, and clerked for a Supreme Court justice. Not bad, considering that he had also taken a few years off in the midst of all that to serve in the Navy during World War II. If the real-life Byron White can be a football star, a Rhodes scholar, a Navy veteran, and a topflight lawyer, then I suppose the fictional Spearchucker can be a football star and a neurosurgeon before ending up in the Army.

-- TopFrog

reply

As you know, in high school those who were on the teams had to skip classes so they weren't exactly the brightest candles on the cake

You're over-generalizing athletes. Some of them *are* that smart.

There was Detroit Lions starting wide receiver who got his MD while he was still playing. Granted, it took him longer than it would a full-time med student. I also remember a starter at Michigan (one of the major "football factory" programs) that left the team a year earlier than expected (by the fans, who don't follow players' academic careers unless it impacts an individual's eligibility) because he was entering the Harvard Law School.

There are people out there who are both extremely smart and extremely athletic.

Also remember that we are talking about a period when the NFL season was shorter (I *think* that it was 12 games during the Korean War era) and when "off season mini-camps" and year round work-out schedules were completely unheard of. So football would *only* impact his schedule in fall semesters.


Now, if you want to argue that he was a bit young to have made it all the way through the neurosurgery sub-specialty with his reduced fall semester schedules, that's one thing (though, it's always possible that he looked several years younger than he was; some people are like that). However, arguing that nobody could possibly have both of those aptitudes just doesn't fly.

In terms of the logistics of possibilities, it is possible that he balanced the light fall class schedules with heavy schedules in the winters and some summer classes.

It's also entirely possible that he only played pro football for a few years and then retired when it came time to do his residency and his surgical specializations. Remember that we are talking about an era when many pro athletes still had other jobs in the off season. Stars didn't have to do that, but even they weren't getting set-for-life money like we are used to being the norm now. He almost certainly stood to make more money as a surgeon than as a football player, so that's not an unreasonable option.

reply

Just because the athletes today can't read and write, doesn't mean athletes then were illiterate too.

reply