I agree completely with the first paragraph. Lee is the best Dracula of the lot. I've seen all the others - Jourdan, Palance, Lugosi, Langella, Oldman and even Paul Naschy's take (which is very different indeed). I've also seen the two versions of NOSFERATU, but I look upon them differently. Max Shreck's Count Orlok is not Dracula at all in my eyes, but he is a highly interesting character in his own right and I felt a bit let down that Murnau didn't realise this and take his story, which was already different, all the way. As for the remake of NOSFERATU, the one with Klaus Kinsky, I find that one to be really awful indeed. I find it awful not least because it's very, very slow paced and boring, but also because it wants to have its cake and eat it - the producers clearly wanted the character to be seen as Dracula but make him look just like Orlok. It was a complete waste in my opinion. I like Kinsky in some of his other roles but he was seriously miscast in that one.
DRACULA: PRINCE OF DARKNESS is my least favourite in Hammer's Dracula series - a sadly flat picture in my opinion. I do like the alternate adaptation of the novel that HORROR OF DRACULA is, though. In particular, Cushing's interpretation of Van Helsing is far more memorable than the others who played the role. And I like it greatly for what it is, please don't misunderstand me as I make my next comment. When I think about the best Van Helsing when seeking an interpretation that closest fits the novel, my favourite is John Arthur Olsen, who played the part in a Full Motion Video game in the early 1990s called DRACULA UNLEASHED. In that game, too, are my favourite portrayals of the Stoker's other characters - Arthur Holmwood, Jonathan Harker, Mina Harker, Dr. Seward and Renfield. All you need to play the game is a DVD player.
Moving on to Jess Franco's adaptation I would add one thing to the comments you have made. Lee's interpretation of Dracula in that movie enabled him to play the role as he wanted but, and this a big but, Dracula had completely lost the sense of total evil you mentioned in your first paragraph. Lee's performance was flat in some parts as well. The sheer energy and intensity he puts into the Hammer Draculas was absent from Franco's version. It's a shame because I like some of Franco's other flicks - SHE KILLED IN ECSTASY (my favourite), VAMPYROS LESBOS and DRACULA'S DAUGHTER.
I like the BBC mini-series version of Dracula with Louis Jourdan. I accept Jourdan's alternate portrayal of the Count as creepy and dangerous in a subtle manner with a tendency towards total arrogance. It was interesting, entirely memorable, certainly re-watchable and makes Jourdan my second favourite Dracula. I agree that Lee should have been cast in this version. Indeed I couldn't have put it better myself.
On a final note, I would say Susan Penhaligon, in the BBC version, is the best actress to portray Lucy Westenra.
reply
share