Movie left so much out....


The book has Jerry feeling up Nancy Putnam in a drunken haze after a party at Cozy Cabins, while Pookie is transporting hung-over party-goers back to the houses~~she was the only one not too drunk to drive! This scene was a big change to their couple dynamic. Another scene that would have been crucial to the desparation of Pookie not to let Jerry go was the one in which they went to New York City for a weekend. That chapter in the book was powerful and sorrowful and it's from NYC that Pookie leaves to go back home. Also never mentioned on screen but very important to Pookie's character, I feel, is that fact that she sent Jerry, about a year after leaving, a suicide note, wishing him well but assuring him there was nothing he could have done to prevent it. Jerry is sorely tempted to get the copies of Pookie's hometown newspaper from around the date of the letter, but does not, in hopes that she did not do herself in. Frankly, I wouldn't have been able to stand it, had I been Jerry! I would have had to know.

There was no supposed pregnancy scene in the book, Pookie's mother is alive, and there is a disturbing part where Pookie is obsessed with the shooting of a crow, which was not in the movie, but I felt important to Pookie's mental problems.

I think the movie suffered (and was just plain boring) b/c these scenes were not included. Even a few of them would have helped. I, too, found the lack of changing seasons hilarious.

reply

Don't get me started... Oops! I guess I already did get started-- check out the "Bloopers and Trivia" thread I put up a couple years ago already.

Believe it or not, many of the scenes you list as missing are to be found in the "final draft" of the movie script (please see TBReed's threads), which also contains the scariest Pookie imaginable. I think the director was aiming for a very different "feel" here, and only used the book and Alvin Sargent script as a skeleton upon which to hang his own most intimate memories and personal observations... then he simply cut out just about everything else! Please check out the "Revealing Quotes" thread (another one of mine, sorry) for more on that.

I think it's great whenever someone who has read the novel posts on this board!

reply

Wow! I would have liked to have seen this version. The book had me convinced that Pookie was mentally ill; the movie just showed her as kind of a pest.

reply

I agree.

RIP Heath Ledger 1979-2008

reply