MovieChat Forums > Sole Survivor (1970) Discussion > Differences between Sole Survivor and La...

Differences between Sole Survivor and Lady Be Good


I just saw the Sole Survivor film on youtube - the video quality is quite poor but given how this is the first time I've seen it since it originally aired in 1970 I'm not complaining. Having recently reread Mario Martinez's 1996 book: Lady's Men: The Story of World War II's Mystery Bomber and Her Crew, I note the following differences:

Movie: The bomber is a B-25
Reality: B-24

Movie: The nickname of the bomber is the Home Run
Reality: Lady Be Good

Movie: The crew consisted of 6 army airmen
Reality: 9

Movie: The navigator (Hamner) abandoned his comrades and jumped over the
Mediterranean
Reality: The navigator (D.P. Hays) jumped with the other 8 men (The bombadier
John Wovraka died when his parachute failed to open)

Movie: The airplane flew 700 miles from the Libyan coast
Reality: 440 miles

Movie: The bomber was returning from attacking Messina
Reality: The bomber was returning from attacking Naples (only they never made it all the way to Naples)

Even though I really dug the ghost aspect of the movie, I'd still like to see a solid cinematic version of the real events of Lady Be Good sticking to what really happened as closely as possible. I think such a movie might even wind up better than Sole Survivor.

reply

No offense intended, but the original post is kind of pointless, IMHO. "Sole Survivor" makes no claims of being "about" the Lady Be Good; it's a different story altogether, with the concept being loosely based on what happened with the Lady Be Good. "Loosely" being the key word. All the differences listed between movie and reality are irrelevent - this isn't a documentary about the real WWII bomber. It's a movie, a work of fiction, an entertainment. And, a movie not even trying (or claiming to try) to tell the story of the Lady Be Good.

Maybe someday, someone will make a movie based on the Lady Be Good. It would be kind of a downer, as no one makes it out alive. With "Sole Survivor"'s supernatural angle, at least they had the luxury of a somewhat upbeat ending, with the boys from the Home Run finally going home (most of the boys, anyway). I'm sure there are documentaries or History Channel specials about Lady Be Good. Meanwhile, I'll enjoy "Sole Survivor" on its own merits.

reply

When the wreck of the Lady Be Good was found, the navigator's work was still in the plane. It turned out he had quit "navigating" the plane on it's trip back to Libya. He counted on being able to get the plane back home based upon the radio homing beacon at the base. It was nighttime, so no one on the plane could see anything to help them know their position.

Because he had quit plotting the planes position, he allowed the pilots to fly the plane to the base and then over it. The beacon continued to show the plane was on course, even though it was headed directly away from the base and into the desert.

So because the navigator didn't do his job, the plane flew deep into the desert and the crew eventually died. In real life, however, the navigator paid with his life for his mistake.



"He was running around like a rooster in a barnyard full of ducks."--Pat Novak

reply