One thing that bothers me
If Suzy's phone was cut, and Gloria had already left, why didn't she even attempt to go to Gloria's apartment/the rest of the house to see if she could use their phone? I imagine that if one phone is cut, the rest in the house are in working order and I can assume that Gloria's parents are out, but you would think a woman in such hysterics would think to go upstairs and at least try to open the door, if there even is one being a basement apartment after all.
Just a thought. I know I will get flak for this, but it really bothers me.