'And Susy, I Just Want You To Know That...'SPOILERS
Perhaps one benefit of being a bit older is that I can report to you on seeing "Wait Until Dark" first run. Well, maybe second. Packed house. They chattered a lot in the early, talky stages, but as the suspense tightened, everybody started to get silent, then to murmur, then to mumble in ever-growing suspense.
Everybody knows that the big scream comes at the climax when "dead" Alan Arkin makes his big leap at Audrey Hepburn -- there was nothing but screaming from that point til the shot of the police car racing up, and that screaming shook the theater.
But an almost equally big scream...of an entirely different nature...came when "nice guy crook" Richard Crenna took his leave of Audrey in the doorway.
Crenna thinks that his portly-partner-in-crime, Jack Weston, has knocked off the SuperEvil Arkin ("We flipped a coin. I lost," Crenna tells Hepburn.)
WE know that Arkin has tenderized Weston to death with a back-and-forth four-wall tire sedan murder weapon.
So we're pretty scared. And (back then), we're figuring: You know, Crenna might get killed out there on the street if Arkin is coming back.
Then Crenna -- having told Audrey (Susy) that everything's going to be alright and Big Bad Arkin (Roat) is dead -- pauses for a farewell close-up in the doorway:
"And Susy, I just want you to know that..."
Crenna gasps. His body jolts and shudders. His eyes glaze and go dead, and then...so does he, falling into the apartment as the Epitome of Evil (Arkin) appears behind him and pulls the knife out of his victim's back with grisly effort.
I wanna tell you.
The audience reaction was roughly this:
Awww...(Crenna's a nice guy, talking nice to her like that.)
Huh? (Why'd he stop talking?)
Wha? (Why does he LOOK like that?)
Wait a second, oh no, oh no, oh no...(he's dead!)
And as Crenna pitched forward dead and Arkin's face filled the screen from the shadows, the SCREAMS began. Everywhere, top of the lungs, getting worse as Arkin removed the knife from Crenna's back and secured the door with his special lock and chain.
The screams took FOREVER to die down from this scene, and things just got super-tense from there, as Arkin tortured Hepburn and Hepburn fought back.
The rather gore-free final ten minutes of "Wait Until Dark," from Crenna's death to the climactic blackout, were nothing but yelling and gasping and cheering (when Audrey stabbed Alan) and then screaming.
One of the best nights in a movie theater I ever spent in my life.
P.S. I was just a kid.