Millie's Accent


I adore Julie Andrews, but couldn't she just ditch the accent for this one movie? Where is it Millie comes from? I can't remember. Oklahoma or something?

reply

it was written for her. Millie is british in the film but i wud have preffered her to be american

reply

No, she's supposed to be American, or at least her family lives in America. I can remember either Millie or Mrs. Meers refering to them somewhere in the film.. Don't think they talk about her being English despite her accent.

reply

In the popular book based on the film, Millie is from Salina, Kansas (my hometown). I think Julie Andrews' accent doesn't detract from the film, which is so wild and crazy anyway -- consider, a girl from central Kansas in the 1920's who can sing at a Jewish wedding? And, you know, she wouldn't be Julie Andrews without the accent.

reply

In the book "The Anderson Tapes" John (Duke)Anderson is from the south.
The screenplay was based around Sean's Anderson being an English citizen
In the book for "The Bedford Incident" Sidney Poitier's role Ben Munceford is blond and blue eyed.
In the book "Van Ryan's Express" Ryan is a much younger man also blond

http://worldofvbphoto.blogspot.com/
http://vbphoto.webs.com/models.htm

reply

Her « Jewish » clearly showed that she wasn't.

reply

This was not unusual back then. Check out Haley Mills's Disney movies. For example, in The Parent Trap, her parents are Brian Keith and Maureen O'Hara. Keith is definitely an American, but O'Hara used an American accent. Regardless, nobody cared that Haley Mills's accent is very English.

http://currentscene.wordpress.com

reply

'could she just ditch the accent for this one movie?' I think if that's all you want, we've had proof that she can do accents. Ever seen footage of My Fair Lady? She did a cockney accent then. You don't have to be british to speak the queens english. I think you'll find that there are people who speak like her all over the world.

reply

True, I've seen this film many times, and have never thought her accent sounded out of place or incorrect...

reply

jazzychicken, where did u see footage of mfl??? i would love to see that... i have the record of her singing as eliza on broadway, but ive never seen anything else about her with MFL.

reply

various places. The most recent being the 'broadway: the american musical' show. There was some snippets of mfl on there. I have the recording too :P She can't have been shocking, she won a tony award, didn't she? Pity she wasn't in the movie, but I've always liked Mary Poppins better anyway :D

reply

I think the perfect upper class English accent simply adds to the comedy in this film - her plum voice talking of being a "country girl" etc. It just adds to the entire *feel* of T.M.M. I am terribly sad, I have two different original cast albums of M.F.L starring Jullie Andrews and I also saw the footage of her in it (I was thrilled to catch it! I have literally been trying to see such clips for years)!!! There is the original broadway one, then another which was recorded especially with a huge orchestra and has them being interviewed afterwards... other than the interview, the other is better me-thinks! (I think I like J.A. just a *bit* too much - but I love you all for liking her too!) :'D

reply

Her Cockney was not very authentic, and her voice is definitely middle-class however it might sound to us. But I think they made no effort to “Americanize" her speaking voice here. What’s the point? I just wish they had given Mary Tyler Moore’s role more play.

reply

In the movie, they say she has a big family, but they never specify where she's from. They *might* say she's from the country, but that could easily be the English countryside, as well. Although, I believe in the B'way play she's from KS.

Honestly, as others have said, I like to think Julie's Millie is from KS, too, though, despite the accent. It just makes the film even funnier.

P.S. For those looking for Julie MFL clips, just search "Julie Andrews My Fair Lady" on YouTube and you'll find an abundance of them.

________________________________________
Check out new Gargoyles comics and DVDs!

reply

Despite specifying her hometown in the book, they never do specify where she's from in the movie, although her family lives in various parts of the US.

reply

and besides, you never hear her before her makeover. Who knows, she might be trying to sound like a high-class theatre or film star ;)

reply

She may have been afraid to try an American accent after the scathing reviews of Dick Van Dyke's cockney accent in Mary Poppins. It's a shame, since James Fox brings it off perfectly, and even going-on-gaga Bea Lille does just fine.

reply

I love her for her accent.

Treat me nice! It's my birthday!

reply

It always amused me that three of the main actors are British - and their accents definitely reflect that. With James, he's supposed to be rich from Long Island, and with the way he tones down his British accent, it works as faux upper class American.

Bea Lillie is devious and prone to Chinese (Hong Kong?) dealings, so her slightly toned-down British accent works, too.

Only Julie Andrews as "Millie" - who is supposed to be from the midwest seems out of place with her accent.

I always thought it created an obvious disconnect - but, then again, because it's Julie Andrews and her bob (stylishly modified from "The Sound of Music"!) - it didn't ruin anything for me.

"Don't call me 'honey', mac."
"Don't call me 'mac'... HONEY!"

reply

It wasn't that unusual back then. Remember Haley Mills? She has an unmistakably British accent and she played the daughter of the very American Brian Keith in The Parent Trap. She also played Pollyanna, who is also an American.

http://currentscene.wordpress.com

reply

The one thing I have always noticed but didn't realize its implication until I understood the term is that Millie says "we had tapioca for pudding", not that "we had tapioca pudding" which I always thought it should have been. I'm guessing that Millie is British solely because pudding is the term British use for dessert.

reply

She wasn't supposed to be American in the original movie. I don't believe she has ever tried to lose her British accent, and it's possible she wouldn't have been able to do so. They didn't have good accent coaches in the 1960s.

It's only in the play, written some 40 years later, that they changed the character to an American, and she's from Iowa, I believe, but I'd have to find the script to be sure.

And, the movie was not written for her. Mary Tyler Moore was originally the star, and the story changed when they "brought Julie Andrews aboard". (read the trivia on the Imdb page).

reply