MovieChat Forums > Magical Mystery Tour (1967) Discussion > A Theme Album or Compilation?

A Theme Album or Compilation?


Do you think that the Songtrack album of Magical Mystery Tour is a theme album, or rather a compilation of EP's and Singles? In the sixties it wasn't available as an album in Britain.


The Album (USA: Capitol 1967)/(UK: Parlophone 1976)

Magical Mystery Tour
Fool On The Hill
Flying
Blue Jay Way
Your Mother Should Know
I Am The Walrus
Hello Goodbye
Strawberry Fields Forever
Penny Lane
Baby You're A Rich Man
All You Need Is Love


Magical Mystery Tour EP (Parlophone 1967)

Magical Mystery Tour
Your Mother Should Know
I Am The Walrus/
Fool On The Hill
Flying
Blue Jay Way


Singles:

Strawberry Fields Forever/Penny Lane
All You Need Is Love/Baby You're Rich Man
Hello Goodbye/I Am The Walrus


The Apple Scruffs Corps, 05
If you want to be hero just watch more TV

reply

[deleted]

Yep, nowadays it's different but it is interesting to see how their psychedelic era consisted of only one proper album, Sgt Pepper. Listening to all that music in chronological order, singles in appropriate places, creates some extra jibes.


The Apple Scruffs Corps, 05
If you want to be hero just watch more TV

reply

I wouldn't say that, It started on Revolver. (which I think is the blueprint for Pepper, and much better than Pepper)To me Magical Mystery Tour is far more 'psychedelic' than pepper is.

I mean on Revolver you have

"I'm Only Sleeping" (somewhat psych)
"She Said She Said" (pop psych)
"And Your Bird Can Sing" (pop psych)
"Doctor Robert" (pop psych)
"Tomorrow Never Knows" (full blown psych)

you also have the single from that era

"Rain" & "Paperback Writer" (rain being far more psych than Writer)

then you have the single

"Strawberry Fields Forever" (psych)/"Penny Lane" (not so psych)

Those are all before Pepper and just as psych as Pepper is really. (even if SFF & PL were recorded at the same time

To me on Magical Myster Tour songs like "Flying", "Blue Jay Way", "Magical Mystery Tour", "I am The Walrus" & "Baby You're A Rich Man" are WAY more psych than anything on Pepper.

as are "All Too Much" and "Only A Northern Song" on Yellow Sub. I think had they actually included "Only A Northern Song" on Pepper and taken off "With A Little Help From My Friends" it would have been a better album

they had a pretty good pop/psych album. Pepper and Revolver are really almost the same album, Pepper is a bit more in focus that's all.

reply

Yeess... I'm just coupling Rubber Soul and Revolver as their mid-period albums. No doubt about "Tomorrow Never Knows" being the one pioneering the new era but in a way "There's A Place" was too. I don't have my Lewisohn now here but I'd bet "Tomorrow.." was one of the first songs they started to work on for their new album. The hiatus they had after Revolver just makes in my opinion the conclusion of the era with their last concert in San Francisco in August 1966.


The Apple Scruffs Corps, 05
If you want to be hero just watch more TV

reply

[deleted]

yeah I think Tomorrow Never KNows was the first song started on the revolver sessions.

reply

It was, yes. I checked it out :)

They wanted to do something different from there on and "Tomorrow Never Knows" was a pretty good response. If you only could find the first UK mono editon of the album which features a slightly different mix of the song.


The Apple Scruffs Corps, 05
If you want to be hero just watch more TV

reply

the version on the Anthology is better I think

reply

[deleted]

I love both of them, I think the anthology version is so different that it caught me a bit off guard, and I think I just liked it better from then on, maybe cause it was different...

reply

Anthology version is the take 1. The released version is take 2, but there is also a rare alternate mix for that take, which appeared only on the initial pressings of the UK mono album. Those are all versions and then there is the mashup on Love.

The Apple Scruffs Corps, 05
If Lennon was alive he'd turn in his grave

reply