MovieChat Forums > Bonnie and Clyde (1967) Discussion > The reason movies shouldn't be remade.

The reason movies shouldn't be remade.


Most people, when they see a movie they like, they only remember the really good parts about the movie. That means that the people who made the original succeeded in making a good movie, because people remembered certain parts. They were especially successful in those parts.

So if you go about making a remake, and you're the typical Hollywood producer without a clue what art is, you pretty much just want to remake those parts of the movie that everyone remembers. Here's the problem: Those parts have already been made pretty much to perfection. If they hadn't been, then the original wouldn't have been successful or popular. There are a thousand ways to do a scene wrong, and about 2 or 3 to do it right. The odds that a remake will choose those iconic moments to remake --- and actually get them right? Not very good. Remakes are always worse than the original, unless of course the original didn't succeed in doing whatever it set out to do. If that's the case, as in The Incredible Hulk, then you are not doing a remake, you are doing a re-imagining.

reply

I actually read that the new one isn't so much a remake, it's supposed to be another story based on the lives of the actual Bonnie and Clyde. I still think it won't be that great, but at they're not going to attempt to remake a classic, right?
Lesson! Lesson! If you see a stranger, follow him! ~ Ed, Cowboy Bebop

reply

[deleted]

IT. WILL. NOT. BE. A. REMAKE!

And do you really think that kids are so stupid, that they will go out and rob banks just because of a movie?

"Mom, I'm gonna go rob banks because Hilary Duff did it! BRB! LAWLS!"

Give me a break.

reply

If kids didn't rob banks back in 1967 after seeing this movie, then why would today's kids go and do that? Kids back then weren't any better than today's kids, though I'm sure that quite a few baby boomers will disagree with me.

~~
Jim Hutton: talented gorgeous hot hunk; adorable as ElleryQueen; SEXIEST ACTOR EVER

reply

Movies like Bonnie and Clyde belongs to a certain time and context. Remaking it nowadays, would diminish partially or completely what made B&C such an icon of the new cinema from the late 60's and 70's.

Besides, who could play half as good (better is out of the question) the same characters? Look at cast! Warren Beatty at his prime, Faye Dunaway, Gene Hackman, Estelle Parsons and Michael J. Pollard. Who could do it better than them? Christian Bale and Scarlett Johansson? Nahhh! never!

If it isn't broken, don't fix it! Remakes from classics sux (almost) always!

reply

[deleted]

Some of the major classics are remakes, such as "The Maltese Falcon" (1941).

~~
Jim Hutton: talented gorgeous hot hunk; adorable as ElleryQueen; SEXIEST ACTOR EVER

reply