Oy, Estelle Parsons...


I was expecting so much more from Parson's performance, seeing as how she was the only one who won an acting Oscar out of the whole cast. I think she was the only factor that dragged the movie down a little bit. She does nothing but scream and act hysterical, which is all well and good, but when done tastefully and not over the top. I can only fathom that she got a nomination for the movie because all five principal actors who played the Barrow gang members (and who all got Oscar nods) had an incredible group dynamic that just exploded off the screen. They all feed off each other and react, rather than just act. That's not an easy feat to accomplish and certainly nothing you see often in recent movies. However, of the five of them to actually win an Oscar, why her? She won over two of the most memorable performances I've ever seen--Katharine Ross (The Graduate is my all-time favorite movie) and Beah Richards (who appears briefly in Guess Who's... but leaves a long-lasting impression)--and I'm still puzzled as to why. Thoughts?

Count each day as a gift; you never know when the wrapping paper's going to run out.

reply

Very odd decision. I only saw minutes before watching the movie that she won the Oscar and I watched her very carefully. Not sure what the Academy were doing that year...

reply

I think the Academy wanted to give one of the five nominated actors an Oscar as one for the movie, if you see what I mean and this category was the easiest to do that. Hepburn and Steiger were big sentimental favourites and probably Pollard and Hackman cancelled each other out.

I agree about Ross and especially Richards, plu the non-nominated Marjorie Rhodes in The Family Way were all in a different league to Parson's here.

Six inches is perfectly adequate. More is vulgar.

reply

wow.. this woman won an Oscar for that role? I could put on a wig and pull off her role. I agree that she was an effective annoying character, but honestly that's not the hardest character type to portray. Maybe the selection wasnt very strong that year.

reply

I loved this film, but I wanted her character to be killed off every time I saw her. She was just so annoying and wouldn't stop crying/screaming.

"I wished Her back but the dead adored Her, Even wild winds sang in chora for Her"

reply

Scream yell scream yell cry cry yell scream-She won an oscar for this?

reply

yeah really... i cant understand why warren and faye didnt win for their parts.

reply

I agree that she was an effective annoying character, but honestly that's not the hardest character type to portray.


Yes, and she pretty much plays this same character in every role I've seen her in. In Roseanne, as Roseanne's mother, and then a Barbra Streisand movie I saw.

reply

...and the real Blanche was still alive when the movie was made, and wasn't happy with her portrayal, since in reality, she wasn't like that at all.

reply