MovieChat Forums > Mannix (1967) Discussion > Mannix vs Rockford.

Mannix vs Rockford.


Which one was better and who was the better detective. Seems like Rockford had more problems with the local police and lived pay check to pay check more than Mannix did.


reply

Well, they are both really cool guys but as far actual detective work goes then probably Mannix is the better actual detective.

But Rockford has a lot more ways to get the job done.

Rockford is way more blue collar then Mannix and is willing to pose as someone else or maybe tell a few lies to get the info he needs.

Rockford is a beer drinker, roadside chili dog and taco regular guy who's clients never pay him.
Where Mannix is a cocktail (bloody marry) drinker, steak and lobster guy who has plenty of money and lives more like James Bond.

Rockford has the better sense of humor but Mannix has the better life style.



reply

John. Your right on the monty. I guess Mannix is the Bond of PI's and Rockford is Dirty Harry. I have not watched Rockford in a long time. That show was on when I was age 3 to 9. So my recollection of it is fuzzy. Although they used to play re runs.

I got into Mannix on reruns in the mid 80's late at night. I should check out some Rockford Files to see if it holds up.

reply

Mannix had his share of money troubles, too. He was far from wealthy (he lived right above his office for Chrissakes) but you're right, it is all a matter of degree. He was clearly more solvent than Rockford was.

reply

To me , Rockford has the upper hand because he was an ex convict and that went along way. Rockford is a Man's Man and a detectives detective! If that makes sense.

reply

Roght they both have good strong points

J Mannix has more fire escape fights
J Rockford has more drive time fights
J Mannix has more hard boiled criminals
J Rockford has more smart alec crooks
J Mannix has to rescute Peggy from kidnappers
J Rockford has to rescue Pappy from thugs
J Mannix has plenty of action packed scenes
J Rockford has plenty of poloroid commercials

That about evens em out
unless you throw M Hartley into the deal
for J Rockford
but J Mannix is on the same network
as E and B Hartley

That still evens em out big time

♪  Not even Mad Scientists
get it right every time

reply

Both great. Rockford was written with a sense of humor. Man was pretty serious. Groundbreaking show with one of the first serious black female role, Peggy as his secretary.

reply

And the show treated Peggy's race in an intelligent way. In other words, little was made of it. Peggy could chew out Joe, and did.

And -- perhaps more surprisingly -- Joe could chew out Peggy, and did. (This second thing took more guts on the part of the producers)

The show seemed honestly, genuinely, not to give a crap about race, and I wish more shows and movies today could take the same attitude.

reply

I prefer Rockford. It was more real life. I enjoyed Mannix but it was more typical of the fairly successful private PI, while Rockford had real world problems. I have every season of Rockford on DVD. A true TV classic.

reply

Well, both Mannix and Rockford get hit on the back of the head a lot when entering a room. But in the case of Rockford, it's done with a comical regularity.

reply

Rockford was more believable.

reply

I just caught my first four or five Mannix episodes. Season 1 and I think I’ve been recording it off MeTV. Rockford was more believable in my opinion too. Mannix gets in fist fights and never gets a scratch while Rockford punches someone and immediately grimaces from hurting his knuckles and wrist. Mannix is able to conveniently knock anyone out whenever it’s necessary to have the person out of the way. In one of the episodes I saw, Mannix repeatedly knocked the Sam guy out in several different scenes. Every other episode Mannix is knocked completely unconscious sometimes with the use of a weapon but he has no ill-effects moments later. Mannix seems to have a gun battle in every episode I watched and there’s so much gun brandishing it’s laughable. In the first season, Mannix was part of an agency with all this computer power to make it seem high tech like Mission Impossible and it comes across as a little too convenient that these computers have every trivial piece of data Mannix would need. There also seemed to be mobile phones in every car Mannix used and the police seemed to all want to help him without any need for explanation. Still, I do like Mannix to get that mid-late 60’s vibe. And the guy does dress impeccably and drive some fantastic muscle cars.

reply

I liked Mannix. My favorite episode (A Ticket to the Eclipse) had him stalked by a killer karate expert (played by Darren McGavin). It was filmed in the Pasadena karate school of the legendary Ed Parker.

reply

Okay, I’ll watch out for that one and write you back when I see it.

reply

I've seen the first seasons of both. Mannix is part of a private investigation service that seems more like a spy organization, well funded and with a lot of clout.
Rockford is pretty much on his own, with some small connections and is always in need of money.
I liked both but I would give the edge to Rockford. He was more resourceful and when he threw a punch it seemed somewhat believable.

reply

Rockford(James Garner)did many of his own stunts, not sure about Connors though.

reply