This is one of my pet peeves, not just for The Forsyte Saga but for many other period dramas as well. I think the first time I noticed it was in "The Go-Between", with Julie Christie and Alan Bates.
It had seemed quite authentic up to the point that Julie returns to her family out of a copse of trees, and we plainly see the strap of her VERY modern bra! I was shocked (I think I was in college). This was what we now call a "gaffe" or something like it. Never mind the white lipstick! This was much worse for an authenticity freak.
The explanation I've always received as to why most period dramas are filled with glaring errors regarding wardrobe and makeup (esp. the womens'), up until the early to mid-1970's, is that they didn't want to depart too far from the fashionable looks of the current period, so as not to alienate viewers. Think of the liberties taken in "Gone With the Wind" or "Wuthering Heights"--ye gods! By the way, one film I can recall that got the 1880's right: "Gaslight", with Ingrid Bergman. SHE was born to wear those fashions.
I understand that departure, from a producer's POV...but I don't CARE about them! I only care about my own suspension of disbelief. It infuriates me when I see ANY kind of makeup on a woman prior to the 1920's! Probably the first ones to totally disregard these things was the Merchant-Ivory crew, which made their films so amazing, along with other aspects.
And then you get films like "Sense and Sensibility", in which the women had to wear, not only period corsets, but to train themselves into them, as young women in the late 1700's would have had to! Now that is dedication in acting and accuracy in film making!
She deserves her revenge, and we deserve to die.
reply
share