Rotter?


Does anyone know why the "You're a rotter..." lyric is usually removed?

reply

I just recorded it off of Cartoon Network, and the rotter line is still in there.

Have you heard the song on the radio yet? "You're A Mean One, Mr. Grinch" sung by Thurl Ravenscroft (Tony the Tiger)?

The rotter line is included in there as well.

The only QUESTIONABLE holiday scene I have seen omitted from a generation Xer show is Santa Claus is coming to Town. The scene of the pile of toys being burned in front of crying children is deleted for rather obvious reasons that it might be distressing today for kids.

It certainly never was for me as a small kid. I know Santa Claus is Coming To Town is hacked to pieced today, songwise.

reply

I had only asked because of what the trivia section says about the removal of that line. I thought there might be some obscenity related to the word 'rotter'. I have two taped versions of the cartoon; one from the early 80's - another from the late 90's. The late 90's version does have the "You're a rotter..." sequence eliminated, while the early 80's version does not.

I suppose it could just be a simple removal.

reply

That's one thing I've never understood about the censors.

It was ok to show it 4 decades ago, but now that children are supposedly maturing at a much earlier age...it's not?






He's back on the horse.
- Mr. Peterman?
Smack, Elaine! White Palace!

reply

DarkPrince: "That's one thing I've never understood about the censors.

It was ok to show it 4 decades ago, but now that children are supposedly maturing at a much earlier age...it's not?"
-------------------------------------------------------------

Well, ABC FAmily has been showing many of these Christmas classics, and I caught "Santa Claus Is Coming To Town" right at the scene-in-question, and guess what?

The toy-burning was included once more. Had I known I would have copied it off. The schoolteacher's song was returned to its original length as well, it seems.

Since I missed both versions of "Toymaker to the King" I would be willing to guess they were intact as well.

Ah well.

reply

I guess if they're cutting for time, that scene during that verse doesn't move the story along any...just more bits with the Grinch making off with stuff. Still, it was there in a recent 'WB' showing.

reply

The only possible reason I can come up with is that it's a particularly British term. Kids on these shores might find it confusing.
cinefreak

reply


I know that the word "rotter" is a British usage which never made it to North America, but there is so much insularity all over the place. Surely asking a child to think about the meaning of a word which it has not previously heard is not taxing its poor little brain too much.Surely any child who really can't figure out the meaning of a word could find someone to ask.
I am Canadian, and as such have access to magazines here from England. These are magazines for grownups-not in the sense of being porn, just with subject matter that would not interest children. They do the same thing-they quote North American interview subjects as using English words which I can almost guarantee North Americans do not ever use. No wonder the general population seems to be getting dumber-these magazines are not discussing nuclear physics,just common everyday happenings If it is necessary to cater to their ignorance,the decrease in what seems to be the amount of knowledge about any world beyond that which exists three inches in front of ones own nose will only continue.

reply

I couldn't agree more. If you don't have curiosity you'll never learn anything. And if you're not challenged in this department it's unlikely that you're going to develop any curiosity. The pervasive culture these days seems to put an emphasis on not taxing anyone in this regard.
I asked alot of questions about alot of things when I was a kid. In retrospect, I must have driven my mother nuts.
About five years ago I was doing a Passover choir job in an upstate New York resort hotel. A bunch of us were sitting at dinner afterwards and the cantor's son came over to our table. With a big enthusiastic smile on his face he looked at the table and said, "The choir are all wankers!", to which three or four of our number replied, "Oh! Thank you!"
I translated and the enthusiasm wained.

cinefreak

reply

Okay ..... I admit I'm being stupid ..... exactly what is a rotter and when was the term used in cartoon? I'm not young. I was born in 1960 and remember seeing on tv when it was originally aired back in the 1960s

reply