HH requires a suspension of disbelief, in many cases, a whole lot of it, including a tunnel system that rivals the Manhattan subway. That's all part of enjoying the show. But there are instances in which the writers let down the viewer by lame plot resolution. In a Season 1 episode I just watched, Klink and the guards discover a tunnel outside the wire. So instead of at least leaving some of them behind to guard the hole, Klink and all of his guards return to the barracks in which the tunnel was located. Meanwhile, the 20 men from another stalag who were "trapped" in the tunnel simply escape from the now unattended mouth of the tunnel outside the wire.
I suppose you could lump that resolution under the 'Klink was really Nimrod and knew all along what was going on' theory. He herds the guards back to the barracks precisely so the men could escape. But since nothing in the show ever really suggests this, other than the fact that all of these events take place under Klink's nose and he never catches on, you're simply left with either that theory or the idea that Klink really is that incompetent/dumb. The problem with both of those posits is that they became too much of a sort of catch-all which was used too often to explain or patch up virtually every otherwise incredible hole in the plots.
I wasn't attempting a debate, I was pointing out that either of those theories were probably considered by the writers as an adequate catch-all explanation for lame plot resolutions.
I just saw the episode with James Gregory playing a Nazi general who thinks he's one step ahead of Hogan. Instead, at the end, the smug general boards his Luftwaffe bomber which has been commandeered by Hogan's men. Hogan pilots the plane to a Nazi oil refinery and Carter the bombardier drops bombs he, himself, manufactured, destroying the target!
There's more. Hogan's team bails out and returns to Stalag 17. The RAF crew remains aboard with the Nazi general, now a prisoner and all fly to London. There's even more. Sergeant Schultz, who was also aboard, bails out too! All unbelievable even for Hogan's Heroes.
I recall one episode where the Heroes had to find a way to slow down a panzer division which needed them to shovel snow and clear the road during a heavy snowstorm. Schultz has a pretty bad cold which Klink catches, so they're both sneezing all the time. Meanwhile there's a threat of an avalanche which the prisoners believe will stop the panzer division. After failing to trigger the avalanche with an impromptu jam session at the Hofbrau, as they're about to be taken back to camp, Klink sneezes and suddenly the avalanche starts.
Of course, it's hard to imagine how anyone can trigger an avalanche with a sneeze, but that was the plot resolution for that episode. Maybe it was just a miracle or something out of I Dream of Jeannie.
There are stories of a slight sound triggering an avalanche so a sneeze would be farfetched if not impossible./
But I'm thinking of episodes that just don't make sense. E.g.,Carter asking permission to escape 'cause his gal at home dumped him. I don't think that qualifies any GI, even a POW, for a trip home. Even more importantly, the escape would ruin Klink's perfect record, which is the main reason a dope like Klink wasn't replaced by a competent overseer.
Also,at the end, the Gestapo drops off Carter at Stalag 13 and departs, no harm done, even though Carter was out of uniform. That's a capital offense and a death sentence the Gestapo would have relished carrying out.
That one with the gonkulator was a bit farfetched. it's just a small electrical fire that manages to burn one guy to a crisp, with no remains of any flesh whatsoever (he escapes). Meanwhile, no one else in the barracks was even injured.
"That one with the gonkulator was a bit farfetched. it's just a small electrical fire that manages to burn one guy to a crisp, with no remains of any flesh whatsoever (he escapes). Meanwhile, no one else in the barracks was even injured."
If you knew anything at all about gonkulators you'd understand why the Germans fell for it.
The ones tonight seemed a bit farfetched as well....why was it necessary to blow the safe? Couldn't they just have rented a room, then tell the hotel manager they wanted to put something in the safe deposit box? Then come back later and want something out, but bring the other key.
There was no guard watching the safe.
If the Gestapo knew the officer was storing something in the safe deposit box, wouldn't they order the hotel to open every box?
The other one - with the 3 female prisoners....couldn't it have been a trap? What, 3 western girls are working a night club near a German rocket base? Surely it wasn't a town with a ton of Allied sympathizers!