crtereon ripping off more fans - Robinson Crusoe on Mars Discussion

[–] blackcauldron 16 years ago

This is "Criterion"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Criterion_Collection

reply

[–] DIONHEATHER 16 years ago

Let me rephrase the question. Who the F does Critereon THINK they are that they can get away ripping off fans by charging $39.00 for a DVD that chould be in the $5 bin?

reply

[–] blackcauldron 16 years ago

Criterion is probably the most respected DVD company. They take time to license films, many that have not been otherwise released (such as this movie), spend money to carefully restore the picture and sound, and gather extras as possible. They also have the best covers for their cases (Warner Bros., who uses many of their original poster covers, comes in second for me). Their films are not for everyone. If fans do not want to spend the $28 for their most expensive films (check Amazon) they should not bother. Also, Criterion films retain their value - unlike most releases (especially those retailing for $35 or so because of "digital copies" or 2 disc sets) which, as you said, quickly end up in the $5 Wal-Mart bin.

reply

[–] 16 years ago

[deleted]

[–] 16 years ago

[deleted]

[–] 16 years ago

[deleted]

[–] sdribble 16 years ago

How is that a 'ripoff'?? You don't want to pay that much, fine, don't buy it. Or, rent it from Netflix and find a way to copy it. Problem solved.

reply

[–] PrickWithAFork 16 years ago

Dionheather, not that you'll care, but that was a really offensive response to a paerfectly polite and informative reply.

My body makes no moan
But sings on:
All things remain in God.

reply

[–] Kammurabi 15 years ago

You just need to pay more attention. Wait for a 50% off sale like I do. I got this for 14 bucks.
Criterion DVDs are worth it. They always have the very best print available for each movie.
Even if you don't care about that, it does have a certain collector's value.

.

reply

[–] haristas 15 years ago

Dionheather thinks ROBINSON CRUSOE ON MARS belongs in a $5 DVD bargin bin. Who's the dickhead here?!!!! May a wholly monkey someday take a dump on you.

reply

[–] thegalaxybeing 15 years ago

I actually like it when something I enjoy gets a Criterion release:

I own Robinson Crusoe on Mars, Carnival of souls, Vampyr, Fiend Without a Face & The Red Balloon. I may have a few more (I own quite a few DVD's. Criterion really takes pride in their releases. I admit there's is usually more expensive, but about every one is like a special edition. There are some others I'd like to see them release. The Gus Trikons movie "The Evil" comes to mind. If you only have a casual interest in a particular movie, then the $5 bin is fine. But there is definitely a market for these well made DVD issues. If Criterion did a release of "Fantastic Planet" I'd jump on it!!

reply

[–] pr1mal_1 15 years ago

Criterion ripping off fans? They are the ultimate fan label...DVDs by Fans for Fans.

Their prices are the way they are because you have to keep a few things in mind. First, they do not own a single film that they have released; they have to license films from other companies and people which means a large percentage of the retail price goes to the owners. They do a meticulous digital restoration (audio/visual) on each and every single film and produce their own special features that all put the big companies to shame.

Keep in mind Criterion is not a billion dollar company like Warner Bros or Fox who can afford to send DVDs to the bargain bins and sell at huge discounts. Also, unlike the big companies, they keep their DVDs in print forever unless their license is pulled.

You think Paramount would have ever released this film on DVD? Criterion's efforts towards film lovers should be commended and they are, constantly. I guess there's always a few, though, that have to be negative.

reply

[–] Orbtastic 15 years ago

They are generally not cheap, especially when you have to import them, but you can shop around and find them cheaper.

The point is there IS no other version of this film on DVD. Prior to Criterion releasing this, you had to buy a overpriced, pretty lousy converted to DVD from VHS from some shady seller on Ebay or whatever.

This print is very clean/clear and it has extras that you won't find anywhere else. Plus by buying it, you are supporting future releases of out of print or hard to find films, rather than supporting people who just care about making a profit by exploiting the unavailablity of good films by pushing out poor versions of films on "DVD".

reply

[–] 15 years ago

[deleted]

[–] babettegillette 12 years ago

And yet Alpha Video DVDs are lasting as long as my(only a couple) Criterions.

reply

[–] ishiidobie 12 years ago

Seriously?
Alpha Video are all public domain releases with no bonus features of any kind. They pay zero in licensing fees. After pressing the discs, designing and printing the artwork, everything is profit, thus their low retail price.
You are comparing apples to oranges you sick and twisted little monkey!
Go suck a duck, tool!

reply

[–] ishiidobie 12 years ago

Basically, because you are an idiot and their only reason to exist is to piss you off.
*beep* tool.

reply

[–] cary_howe 11 years ago

I used to pay twice that for Criterion laserdisks and was happy to get them. The fact is kids today are spoiled. Criterion spends a bundle digging up rare content and mastering the films knowing they will likely sell under 10,000 copies. You're paying for quality. If you aren't willing to pay for quality wait until Anchor Bay releases a cheapie version and it'll soon end up in your cherished bargain bins. You might as well throw a fit that Porsche won't release a $10,000 supercar for you. Ain't gonna happen.

reply