Herc's logic


CONTAINS SPOILERS

So the Argonauts arrive on the Island of Bronze to gather food and water. But first, Jason warns them not to take anything else. If they do, they'll have to deal with the island's guardian, Talos. Hercules, however, tells them not to worry, since he's the son of the king of the gods and has battled monsters and self-proclaimed heroes from across the world, Talos would have to be completely stupid to want to pick a fight with the son of Zeus.

This...actually makes sense. We've all heard this cliched story of being warned not to, but doing it anyway. But here, we get a reason for Herc's stupidity; his ego. And why not, he's protected by Zeus, he's super-strong, and he's never lost a fight. So why should he be afraid of Talos?

So, our heroes go exploring. Herc and Hylas stumble across a giant bronze statue of Talos.

So, wait, Talos is just a statue? Wow, we got worked up over nothing.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pmu5sRIizdw

So the two find a treasure chamber and Herc sees no harm or shame in helping himself to the treasure. After all, it's not like the island is guarded. But, just as they head out, Talos comes to life and attacks.

"Okay, Herc, you're on!"

"Uh, I didn't know he'd be a bronze giant."


Oops.

But I love Herc's logic here. As misguided as it is, it makes sense. It's not like Odysseus's crew mistaking a sack containing the wind for a bag of treasure that Odysseus wasn't going to share with them, even though he's very trustworthy.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LMuplGLPD_Q

But overall, it's a good, well-written scene. And I always love seeing Herc's reaction when he finds out that Talos was more than even the son of Zeus could handle.

Brother Maynard, bring forth the holy hand grenade!

reply

[deleted]

Your comment had me grinning.

---
Ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn

reply

Yeah, that was a great OP post. Very thoughtfully written, and it gave me a chuckle, too.
Thanks to jwhale9382.

I haven't seen "Jason and the Argonauts" for quite some time -it's been at least 5 years. It was one of my favorite movies as a kid. I saw it for the first time in the theater with my family as a kid when I was just 6 years old, and later on TV in the late 60's when I was a bit older. Recorded it last Sunday on TCM and plan to watch it this weekend -thought I'd skim these threads in the meantime. I don't remember Herc making those remarks in their entirety, but my memory ain't getting any better, that's for sure. I do remember that it almost seemed as though Jason knew what was going to happen, because he seemed to really make an effort to make his point clear to Herc in particular.
Can't wait to see it again! I'll really pay attention to that scene.

reply

[deleted]