MovieChat Forums > Hud (1963) Discussion > One of the first 'anti-heroes' in 60's p...

One of the first 'anti-heroes' in 60's popular culture


I was 10 when this film came out, and I remember it caused something of a stir at the time. I was vaguely aware of the movie's existence through TV and magazine ads, but primarily because a female cousin of mine in Dallas, who was either just graduating high school or starting college, was just crazy about the film, and Paul Newman's Hud character.

I remember hearing adults (my parents and their acquaintances) negatively discuss the movie as kind of "sick" because the main character was a selfish jerk who was really a villan, but because of Newman's charismatic portrayal, was perversely attractive, and came off as sort of a hero, which they definately felt was morally wrong.

Shawn Levy, in his 2009 biography of Newman ("Paul Newman - A Life"), writes that the principles involved in making the film, primarily Newman and director Martin Ritt, were also surprised at the public reaction to the character of Hud Bannon. They "...had intended an indictment of a certain strain in the American character, and they were genuinely taken aback when the film's strength at the box office was explained, in good measure, by the fact that a young audience saw Hud not as a heel but as a role model." Levy quotes Ritt as saying "I got a lot of letters after that picture from kids saying Hud was right...the kids were very cynical; they were committed to their own appetities and that was it...that's why the film did the kind of business it did -- kids loved Hud... that son of a bitch that I hated, they loved."

Looking back at it, Newman's "Hud" was really one of the first of the so-called "anti-heroes" of 1960's American popular culture.

reply

TCM aired this twice the last couple of days, and Robert Osborne dealt with the idea of Newman as the anti-hero in Hud. Newman and director Martin Ritt didn't intend that perception and were very surprised when fans started to look at Hud Bannon as a cool anti-hero.

"Congratulations, Major. It appears that at last you have found yourself a real war." Ben Tyreen

reply

He is not at all an anti-hero, but he is sympathetic. Its clear that Huds father may have been a great and honorable working man, but he was a lousy father whose wife died and left him with two kids he couldn't raise. The irony of it is that it is in fact Hud's father that is somewhat selfish and uncaring about Hud.

I really like the line at the end. When the kid says "granddad, youve never quit on anything in your life" and the old man looks up at Hud. I thought he might lament that he quit on Hud. But of course he gets stubborn and says something mean to Hud and then dies.

Hes a selfish man in disguise as a good noble man. Its one of those tragic ironic things. The old man even says how could a man like you come from a man like me. Well. Theres your answer.
-T

reply