The Gunfighters


Why was this wonderful serial so criminally under-rated? It's one of the best of the the Hartnell era!

reply

It's ages since I've seen. I never thought it was the best but I can't remember thinking it was the worst either. Will maybe have to rewatch

reply

They do reuse a certain song a bunch, but I enjoyed that. I can see how if you didn't like that song you might not like the episode. But I love Doc Holliday, and Dodo, and all the other characters really. Even William Hartnell seems a bit better in this one. I usually find him too dour.

reply

It's personally not one of my favorites, but I enjoyed it well enough.

I suspect to the extent that it's lower-rated among Hartnell's stories, it may be because purely historical stories aren't as interesting to many as the ones with more science-fiction elements. Not only that, but this is heavily western influenced, which isn't always a favorite of people.

When it comes to Hartnell, I'd probably through The Gunfighters somewhere in the middle. I did love the recurring "Last Chance Saloon" song, because is cracked me up. Overall, though, there's other Hartnell stories that I think people gravitate toward.

reply

Of course, as historical stories, go, "The Gunfighters" happens in an alternate universe to our history. You can't count on any plot event in it geing correct any more than you can in Star Trek"s "Specter of the Gun".

I remember the song partially.

When Warren Earp was killed the song included the phrase "They've done for poor Warren", even though Warren Earp didn't die for another 19 years until 1900.

And one time there were the lines:

"When the Earps meet the Clantons, the lead it will fly.
When the Earps meet the Clantons, young men they will die."

and that is historically accurate enough, I guess.

Warning! Spoiler Ahead! Don't Read!



Of course my favorite part is when Johnny Ringo checks into the hotel, being called in for the gunfight. Charlie says he can't wait to see Wyatt Earp's face when he hears, but Ringo tells him not to warn Earp. As Ringo goes upstairs to his room, he turns and tells Charlie he knows Charlie won't tell Earp, and then shoots Charlie, who slumps dead over the counter.

And the song says:

"He knew Johnny Ringo, and he spoke his name aloud,
so Charlie the barman has gotten a shroud."

And the next episode beings with the Doctor and companions comming downstiars and seeing Charlie slumped over the bar and assuming he is sleeping off a binge. Some doctor!

reply

Does anyone know the complete lyrics to the song in "The Gunfighters"

reply

The movie Gunfight at the OK Corral (1957) isn't any more historically accurate than "The Gunfighters" or "Specter of the Gun" but is entertaining and has a great opening sequence and song.

I note that some online lyrics sites make an error, saying:

Oh my dearest one must die
Lay down my gun or take the chance of losing you forever

When the lines are actually

Oh my dearest one must I
Lay down my gun or take the chance of losing you forever

If you watch a video of the opening sequence and it doesn't have the final stanza about Boot Hill, keep looking until you find one that does.

The opening song of Gunfight at the OK Corral (1957) is one of my favorits from the movies, right up there with High Noon and Flash Gordon (1980). But the song in "The Gunfighters" is also quite catchy.

reply