Atticus's Kids


Is there a single time in the movie where his children obey him?

reply

I think that is the point. Atticus is raising his kids not to obey HIM, but to have high morals and obey their own consciences.

reply

Yes, they did obey his request to come inside after the neighborhood was disturbed by Mr. Radley firing his shotgun, after he told them at least twice.

Actually, I have seen the movie several times recently as well as reading the book, and found myself wondering the same thing. (In the book there are many more orders, such as to leave the Radleys alone, not play games based upon them, and so on.) In the film I remember once, and once only, when the children did what Atticus said without arguing or having to be told again, although he did take care to say it twice. After shooting the mad dog, he says not to go near it as "he's as dangerous dead as alive," and as he leaves, he repeats, "Remember, don't go near that dog!" at which Jem answers, "Yes, sir." I had a fascinating false memory which I can't explain concerning the scene immediately following this. I was sure that after Atticus was out of sight, Jem walked over and looked at the dog, staying at least six feet away--not touching it, but going near enough for a closer look. I was startled that this didn't happen, double-checked, and sure enough, as Atticus leaves, Jem is holding onto a telephone pole at the curb, and the scene ends in a dissolve, not a cut--so there can be no other version including the longer scene I recalled. I wondered if the memory could have been from the book instead, checked that also and it says the same as the film--they waited at a distance for Zeebo to pick up the dog and did not approach it. I was a bit put out at misremembering as usually my memory is quite accurate, especially on things I have seen several times.

reply

How many children do you know who usually obey their parents the first time the parents ask or tell them to do something? They clearly obeyed him when he told them twice to come in and get ready for bed and when he told them not to go near the dead dog.
As for the children bothering the Radley's and going to their house against Atticus' orders, the townsfolk talked bad about the family and the children believed them and this made the house and family curious to them. And children have a hard time exercising self control over curiosity. Only when they were shown that what was said about at least Arthur Radley wasn't true did the movie imply that the children would no longer bother them.

reply