The worst episode...


I've been searching for complete episodes of Johnny's "Tonight Show" on youtube. Most are very enjoyable. Some are a tad boring. But, I think I've located the absolute worst episode...

Tuesday July 22, 1986 - Walter Matthau, Dick Rutan, Jeana Yeager

Watch it if you dare...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FVOnTwzU7B4

The monologue is a stinker. The prop theft/security guard bit is the most painfully unfunny sketch I've ever seen and they devote 10 minutes to it! Even Johnny knows it's bad.

The pilots are boring. Walter Matthau and Johnny spend most of their time together spelling words. I feel sorry for the studio audience that waited in line for this mess. A performance by scheduled, but bumped, band Katrina and The Waves (1985's "Walking on Sunshine") would have probably been the highlight of the show!

Johnny could do no wrong between 1970 and 1980. It was around the mid-80s that things started to get rotten. I guess he realized that he was nearing retirement and just didn't have the passion to achieve comedic excellence anymore. Same goes for the talent pool of writers. In the 70s, the monologues and skits were smart, bizarre, finely crafted, and expertly performed by Johnny. By the mid-80s, with cable television, comedy writers had more options for employment.

Is there an episode on youtube that you think is worse? I'll watch it! I bet it's better than this one!

reply

[deleted]

A lot (and I mean a lot) of Carson's later shows suck. It pretty much just comes down to how much they suck. In the great pantheon of bad shows, I doubt the Matthau or Randall shows come even close. That's how bad the really bad shows were. There just aren't all that many good shows after the deal Carson made with NBC in 1980. By then, Carson was way past his prime and Fred Silverman definitely should have let him go. The late night host who was funny and original back then was Letterman.

Ironically, George Miller was actually quite a good friend of David Letterman and his appearances on Late Night/Show weren't half bad. And to show how close a friend Letterman was, he actually paid for Miller's expensive cancer treatment before he died.

reply

[deleted]

A lot of episodes from the late 70's are tough to watch. Carson looked bored - guests would come on and he would just let them ramble. It was clear he was sick of the 90 minute format.

reply

[deleted]

Occasionally, Carson could actually have a good, entertaining interview, but it depended entirely on who he was interviewing. An example on one of the recent Antenna shows was Sam Donaldson. I'm not much of a fan of the guy, but he interviewed well with Carson. It's a real shame just about all of the sixties' shows are gone. I have a hunch that, back then, Carson was a much better interviewer, much closer to, say, Jack Paar.

But as the years went on, those types of interviews became more and more rare and, yeah, Dick Cavett, aka 'The Thinking Man's Carson' was much better in a civil discourse with his guests. Ironically, Cavett was originally a writer on The Tonight Show for Carson and it's very telling how Carson and Cavett maintained a good relationship throughout their respective careers unlike, say, Joan Rivers.

It really would be great to see some of those old Cavett shows, but I doubt many were saved. Cavett didn't have anything like Carson's power, and it's probably a foregone conclusion that, with the exception of a handful of shows, they're all gone. One of my favorites was when Sophia Loren and Marcello Mastroiannni got into a heated debate about male-female relationships.

Carson's focus and demeanor really shifted to light, Burt Reynolds-type fluff when he moved the show to LA, and he had to know it. The so-called interviews became nothing more than plugs for whatever the guest was starring in or publishing. Letterman wasn't far off, having once said that if you wanted to appear on his show, you had to have three anecdotes to retell. But Letterman had other, original stuff that he could also use whereas Carson was down to the same, tired bits he'd been using for the past decade (or more).

Cavett wasn't like that; there weren't any dumb comedy bits (that I can recall) and he could keep the interview interesting without resorting to cheap one-liners. I suspect that although Carson's fortunes increased substantially in Burbank, this is when his actual, off-camera, real persona got worse and worse, simply because he knew his show had become total garbage compared to the earlier, New York shows.

reply

[deleted]