MovieChat Forums > West Side Story (1961) Discussion > Both Jets and Sharks bear responsibility...

Both Jets and Sharks bear responsibility for loss of lives on both sides:


A rumble was eminent from the beginning in West Side Story. All the skirmishes between the Jets and Sharks, as well as the showdown at the dance invariably led up to that, in the end, and it was bound to lead to the loss of lives.

Had there been no loss of lives, and people on both sides were seriously injured, but survived, I could and would say that the newly-arrived Puerto Rican Sharks were defending themselves and fighting for their right to a piece of terrain, as well.

Since lives were lost on both sides, however, I have to say that both the Jets and the Sharks bear responsibility for the loss of lives. Riff, Tony and Bernardo, who had a history of gang leadership and the perpetration of violence, all three of them ultimately ended up on the receiving end of it, with the subsequent loss of their lives.

What I noticed at the end of the original 1961 film version of West Side Story is that Maria, despite being devastated by the loss of Tony, walked off in the procession together, after several Jets and Sharks came together to help carry Tony's body off, thus presenting a ray of hope, and possible reconciliation and the development of friendships between the Jets and Sharks. The interesting thing about this film version of West Side Story is that it leaves possibilities wide open to the audiences' imagination.


reply

Yeah. This is why I hate it when I go see stage productions of West Side Story and they leave out the part where both gangs carry away Tony’s body.

reply

I see your point, StrongRex. You're right.

reply

Of course! They've all joined street gang whose purpose is to fight with other street gangs, there are no good guys or bad guys, they're ALL throwing their lives away!

There only "right" side in this fight is Tony and Maria's side, the side that says "Stop fighting!", or "Those fools won't stop fighting, let's leave".

reply

You've also made some interesting points, Otter, but the fact that Tony and Maria never did succeed in getting away, as they'd planned to do (i. e. Tony was shot and killed by an angry and jealous Chino), at least in part because he stabbed Chino's close friend and right-hand man, in retaliation for his having killed Riff, indicates that escaping that kind of a harsh environment is far easier said than done.

reply

Sadly, that's true for many illegal organization, they don't let anyone leave, it threatens the organizational unity and the egos of anyone in power... so anyone who says "Fuck THiS" to a gang is likely to be made an example of.

Still, it's shocking to see the deaths in "WSS", because the characters are written as very young and at the start of the story, the worst any of them have ever done is hit people. I don't think most of them had ever done anything with their knives, except wave them menacingly, the tragedy of the story is seeing these kids tip into really serious crimes.

reply

You've made some good points, Otter. However, the fact that the Rumble ended up with Riff and Bernardo ending up duking it out at the Rumble with switchblades indicates that this is where the Rumble was bound, in the end. In real life, switchblades, chains, and even fisticuffs were commonly used during gang rumbles. As a neighbor of mine said a number of years ago, while I was on my way to a screening of the old, original 1961 film version of West Side Story succinctly pointed out: West Side Story, while it's fiction, is closer to reality, in some aspects.

Escaping the streets and gang life is far easier said than done, as well.

reply

[deleted]