Updated Odd Anthology List
Here is a list of most of (If not All) of the B&W era mystery/horror/sci-fi/fantasy anthologies including the well known ones. If you like "Thriller" some of these others may appeal as well.
Title-------------------------------------1st telecast..........Seasons.......# episodes.......Host (network)
Lights Out (Local NYC run)--------June 30, 1946..........1....................4...............Bill Woodson (NBC)
Suspense---------------------------March 1, 1949.........6....................260...........Rex Marshall (CBS)
Lights Out--------------------------July 19, 1949...........3....................157...........Jack LaRue/Frank Gallup (NBC)
Hands of Murder-------------------Aug. 31, 1949..........3...................101...........Unknown(DuMont)
Danger-----------------------------Sept 19, 1950..........5....................240...........Richard Stark CBS)
Tales of Tomorrow-----------------Aug. 1, 1951............2....................85.............Roger De Kovan (ABC)
Out There--------------------------Oct 28, 1951............1....................12.............None? (CBS)
Inner Sanctum----------------------Jan. 1, 1954.............1.....................39............Paul McGarth (Synd)
Science Fiction Theatre-------------April 1, 1955............2....................78............Truman Bradley (Synd)
Alfred Hitchcock Presents----------Oct 2, 1955..............7....................268..........Alfred Hitchcock (CBS/NBC)
Panic--------------------------------Mar 5 1957............1....................18.............Westbrook Van Voorhis (NBC)
Suspicion----------------------------Sept 30, 1957.........1....................42............Dennis O’keefe/Walter Able (NBC)
No Warning-------------------------Apr 6 1958.............1...................13.............Westbrook Van Voorhis (NBC)
One Step Beyond--------------------Jan. 20, 1959.........3...................98.............John Newland (ABC)
The Veil-----------------------------1958.......................N/A..............10.............Boris Karloff (Unsold)
The Twilight Zone-------------------Oct. 1, 1959............5...................156...........Rod Serling (CBS)
13 Demon St.-----------------------1960.......................N/A..............13.............Lon Chaney Jr. (Unsold)
Thriller------------------------------Sep. 1, 1960............2...................67.............Boris Karloff (NBC)
Way Out----------------------------Mar. 31, 1961.........1...................14.............Roald Dahl (CBS)
Great Ghost Tales-------------------July 6, 1961.............1...................12.............Frank Gallup (CBS)
The Alfred Hitchcock Hour----------Sep. 1, 1962...........3...................93.............Alfred Hitchcock (CBS/NBC)
The Outer Limits---------------------Sep. 1, 1963...........2...................49............Vic Perrin (ABC)
All were 30 min except Thriller, Alfred Hitchcock Hour, The Outer Limits, Suspicion & season 4 of The Twilight Zone. Also all were B&W Except season 1 of Science fiction Theatre and possibly Great Ghost Tales (not sure). Some Host information may be incomplete.
Hands of Murder had title changes to Hands of Mystery & Hands of Destiny.
According to some sites Panic & No Warning are really the same show (Titled Panic the first season & No Warning the second).
At least some episodes from all of these exist with the possible exception of Hands of Murder, Out There & Great Ghost Tales. (It seems episodes of Great Ghost Tales does exist, though not available at present)
Note: Many of the older "Live" series (especially before 1955) have a quaint look to them and may not appeal to all tastes.
Also note: I will try to keep this list updated as more facts become available. I try to use multiple sources to keep the info on this list accurate. It is, however, possible for minor errors to slip though.