MovieChat Forums > The Oregon Trail Discussion > Reworked after principal photography wra...

Reworked after principal photography wrapped?


As "dinky-4" points out in his/her user comment, a love triangle sub-plot is set up fairly early on and then surprisingly abandoned later in this picture. Furthermore, despite the title, the story ends well before the wagon train reaches Oregon (that it does do so is implied with an actorless montage of the wagons [definitely either second-unit work or stock footage] and a voice-over song, leading into the closing titles). I also note that the actors who appear ONLY in the scenes involving President Polk are uncredited, and the one character therein who is featured prominently throughout the remainder of the film is completely unrecognizable. Admittedly, the audience is supposed to be in the dark as to this person's identity, but it seems to me that it is simply a different actor here. Given that and the lack of billing for the others, I can't help but suspect that these scenes were filmed and dropped into the picture after it was "completed," and perhaps others deleted. All this makes me suspect that the film was significantly reworked between principle photography and release. Does anybody have any specific and factual knowledge to support or refute this theory?

reply

One thing is for sure, William Bishop (Captain Wayne) was dying of cancer during filming. Indeed, his last scene was a rather hasty and not very well edited goodbye to Nina Shipman. He is limping rather noticibly as he walks to his horse.
The film structurally is a disaster yet it retains a certain charm as old timers like Macmurray, Hull, Carradine, Dierkes and Bishop give it all they've got despite a budget that is non-existant. I like this film a lot-

reply

William Bishop passed away from cancer one month after this film was released
(September 1959).

reply

Talanted film editor/director Gene Fowler gives it his best, unfortunately a tight budget undermines this otherwise entertaining oater. Lots of stock footage (Does that opening wagon trail shot look as if it was used in "Blazing Saddles"?) and "maybe" a day or two at Fox's Malibu ranch are about all of the Oregon Trail we ever get to see. I'm guessing Fox released this on the bottom half of a double bill. Director Fowler interviewed for a film mag, claimed that the budget was so low, Fox wouldn't allow him a camera crane! I tend to agree with the original poster, either this film was heavily reworked in post production, or a lot of scenes were never shot. As always it's great two see two hams like Henery Hull and John Carradine. Both turn in rather low key performances for a change. In closing, it's a good bet that if it had been made a few tears earlier "The Oregon Trail" would have been released in B&W and Regalscope with Scott Brady in the lead.

reply

ssscotchplains: Thank you for the information about William Bishop. His illness could easily have been a factor in what I observed.

Otherwise, yes indeed, I agree fully about the actors. Good work all around. I have long been especially fond of Mr. Carradine's performance here. I did not intend to be slamming the final product, but on reread now I see how I might well have come across as down on the picture, my poor writing, for which I apologize.

reply