MovieChat Forums > The Young Lions (1958) Discussion > The scene in the Hospital

The scene in the Hospital


The scene in the hospital when Christian visits Captain Hardenberg is one of the most powerful things i have ever seen, and Brando is particularly amazing, the anguish and horror he feels to see his captain whose face has been destroyed-no eyes , nose jaw, his face one huge bandage, the pacing , the way the scene is shot, particularly when the captain asks him to bring him the Bayonet:" oh its not fro me its for him," then the captain walks over to show Chrsitian a man even worse wounded then him-Brando's reaction to all this horror sells the scene perfectly.
There is a transformation of Brando's character in this scene, he loses the pretended soldiers hardness, and becomes a human being again, its as though he was trained and drilled to think a certain way and suddenly all that melts away. He loved and hated Captain Hardenberg-and is the suffering of Hardenberg who has is now blind that allows Christian to see.

reply

Read the book...you'll get a different viewpoint from the same event. In the book, Christian is a Nazi right up to the end. The film de-Nazified him in order to make this production more appealing to the average movie-goer.

In the book, Christian is a hard-core Nazi. Not so in the movie. He becomes more and more "human" (anti-Nazi).

Hell, they should have had him become a medic. Then he could have rescued wounded soldiers...and they could have had him say: "Healing is so much better than heiling!"



Every time you make a typo...the errorists win...

reply

"Healing is so much better than heiling!"


Good one! (Thanks for the laugh).

reply