MovieChat Forums > Sweet Smell of Success (1957) Discussion > What was the underlying story?

What was the underlying story?


Around this time in Hollywood it was difficult to get anything made that would disturb the status quo. If you watch Scorsese's documentary I think its called "A journey through movies" he calls the directors that went against the status quo "smugglers" because they had to hide messages in their stories. I think he hinted at Macarthyism in this film. Has anyone heard about any of this?

reply

Hello Orange,

Well, this film more than HINTS at the tyranny of McCarthyism; columnist
Walter Winchell--the real-life model for J.J.--was an ally of Joe McCarthy, and used the same dirty tactics against anyone who dared disagree with him over what exactly consituted a "Loyal American." In the newspaper smear that J.J. & Sidney plant about musician Dallas, it calls him a "card-carrying Party member."

These same methods are still in use. Today is January 30,'07; in just
the last week, a false smear that originated on the Internet has been circulating through "mainstream" media, concerning Senator Barrack Obama.
Only now--in the 21st century--the Boogeyman is no longer "Reds Under The Bed",
but "Muslims In The Mall."

Be sure to catch these excellent films about McCarthyism:

"Guilty By Suspicion", with Robert DeNiro (Scorsese has a role, too.)
"The Front", with Woody Allen.
"Citizen Cohn", with James Woods.
"Tail Gunner Joe", with Peter Boyle.


Gary In Arizona




















reply

thanks, i will do

reply

It is well known that "High Noon"(1952) is also a metaphor for McCarthism and the troubles the writer had(none of his colleagues and friends had helped him)

THE WORLD IS YOURS

reply

Oh,I forgot Rififi(1955) by the great Jules Dassin,which is also,in some extent,a metaphor for McCarthism...

THE WORLD IS YOURS

reply

yeah i saw that - i was just wondering if this film was aimed at mccartysim or anything like that. Pacino is supposed to be remaking Rififi

reply