The lady does look a lot like Julie looks in pictures taken from this period- with very dark hair and similar cut. She was certainly in New York at the time. She could have done it as a lark, especially since the elegant, sexy dress and the leering look David White gives her were contrary to her image at the time. (The woman trying to break up the fight in the previous scene doesn't look like the same woman at all to me.)
The problem I have with it is that Julie, while not the major movie star she would become in the next decade, was already a noted performer. She'd had two Broadway hits, "The Boy Friend", (1954) and My Fair Lady, (March 1956). She'd been on the Ed Sullivan show twice and on the cover of Life Magazine. She'd been on TV in "High Tor" with Bing Crosby and did Cinderella live on 3/31/57 before over 100 million people, (SSS was released three months later). It would seem to me that she would have rated a speaking part, even if she was doing a cameo just as herself.
I have three biographies of Julie- by John Cottrell, by Robert Windeler and by James Arntz and Thomas Wilson. None of them mention Julie being in this film. They do mention Julie spending nearly all her time on the play, which included matinees. She's quoted as complaining that she has no time or energy for anything else and is always turning down invitations to parties, etc. Windeler's book has a telling quote:
"But Julie Andrews was not thinking of movies in the late 1950's, except to attend the occasional special film. (She and Tony accepted as one of the 'perks' of her new stardom, reserved seats to the sold out Around the World in 80 Days.) In fact, she had no show-business aspirations beyond My Fair Lady, she said "I'd like to have worked awfully hard for another two years, then marry, then have lots of children. I really wouldn't mind retiring or working in London on one thing a year. I haven't much desire to go onto bigger or better things-what could be bigger and better than this?"
That, of course wouldn't rule out an appearance as an extra in SSS as a lark or for a friend. But the Windeler book lists in detail the offers she got in that period and the things she did but says nothing about this film. I suspect if that's really Julie, something would have been said about it at some point.
For another example of a supposed film appearance by a future star long before their "official" film debut see "Footlight Parade, (1933). That one turned out to be a near-look-alike and this one probably is, too.
reply
share