MovieChat Forums > The Harder They Fall (1956) Discussion > Has some things in common with Wilder's ...

Has some things in common with Wilder's Big Carnival...


This is one of my favorite boxing films and one of my favorite Bogart films. I just finished watching it again and seeing Jan Sterling in it reminded me of Billy Wilder's Ace In The Hole.

Both stories involve down-on-their-luck newspapermen looking to score big; Kirk Douglas's Chuck Tatum wants a story that will put him back on top, and Bogart wants that big payday so he can walk away.

Both stories also involve a big lie: Toro really can't fight, all his matches are fixed. In Ace, the trapped miner can be easily rescued within a day or so, but Tatum, in collusion with the sheriff and the contractor, choose a longer method so the story can build and newspapers can be sold.

Both films are gritty, b&w fifties film noir; both had excellent music scored by the great Hugo Friedhofer.

Jan Sterling is great in both films, but she plays completely different characters. In Ace, she's the trapped miner's wife, a really unlikeable person; here, she's a sympathetic character who's really Bogie's conscience.

However, Ace has a downbeat ending while Bogart's Eddie Willis fights back and begins to redeem himself.

Two of my favorites from that era.

reply