the flamenco dancer
Why do they frame the shot so you only see him from the waist up, clapping? You want to see his footwork not his handwork.
shareWhy do they frame the shot so you only see him from the waist up, clapping? You want to see his footwork not his handwork.
shareMost likly because the actor didn't have an idea about flamenco. Remember that the entire part in "Spain" was actually filmed in Mexico and starring Mexicans.
shareIf you click on the link to José Greco on the credits for this movie on the IMDb, you will see that he was for real. Also, the bullfighting scene appears to have been done in Chinchón, a town outside of Madrid, Spain, that I know well. Check out the photos and especially the "virtual tour" at www.ciudad-chinchon.com. The plaza in the center of town in where they set up the bull ring, and is Chinchón's claim to fame. If you go to the website above, click on the British flag to get the English version, go to "Celebrations and Festivals", there you'll see "Chist's Passion During Easter Week", just above it is a link, barely visible, that says "Bullfights in Chinchón", there you will learn that this plaza has been in use since the Middle Ages. Other links at the foot of the page explore the history of the site a bit more. Don't miss the wide angle photo of the plaza at the foot of this page. Again, the photo does not show the plaza decked out for a bull fight, but the image from the movie is unmistakeable. There is the same cathedral above the plaza, and the Romanesque tower to the left. ¡Viva los toros! ¡Viva España!
shareMexicans have alot of pride in their Flamenco dancers and Bullfighters. Just like in Espana, the traditions continue to this day.
shareThey do show his feet and boots, at some point, but "below the belt" was probably not allowed at the time. I do love how the scene is staged, from the opening closeup of the guiter player, to the slow backward pan of the entire scene, and the dance numbers with the women and Cantinflas. Flamenco solo dancing seems kind of boring in comparison...more noise that anything else !
Thanks for you comments..
RSGRE
[deleted]
To the OP, I can see why they may have shown him from only the waist up. In his first scene, did you get a look at him from the waist down when the hotair balloon landed in the city square? Oh my!
"...and I would've gotten away with it if it weren't for those meddling kids."
I tried watching this again today. I realize it must have seemed quite different in 1956. (And I'm not young at all, I was three years old when the film was released.) I managed up to the landing of the balloon in Spain, and the balloon in the flamenco dancer's pants was captured with amazing clarity by the Todd-A-O camera. I gave up--again--shortly after that.
Maybe someday I'll get through the whole thing. But, Oh, my! indeed!
I loved this film as a kid, but agree that the whole Spain sequence, including the bull fight, gets very tedious and wasn't in the book anyway. Once you get past Spain, the pace definitely picks up.
shareI didn´t want to see either; pretty much fast forwarded through the scene.
"facts are stupid things" - Ronald Reagan
They were Spaniards (as in from Spain, not Latin America). Apart from Greco, you can recognise many Spanish stars of the time, like the great Lola Flores. The bullfighters were also the best of Spain at the time, Dominguin, Curro Romero... Big myths in Spain.
shareYou appear to have seen an edited version of the film.
As of 2012, the entire film is on Youtube; look for part 3/12, and you'll see the entire Flamenco scene in which the dancer is on the table stomping for a minute of so before the "waist-up close-up" you're referring to. (And it's clearly the same person.)