Adam was a bastard


That's about all you can say about him, he was a bastard for all his supposing to be so holy and good and righteous, bastard through and through, it's amazing Cal ever wanted love from that thing. If it had been me I would've left home and never returned, not that he would notice anyway.

And the whole thing about the money, Cal is not making a profit off anybody's misfortune, the war is on, nothing's going to stop that, and he's not making a profit off the soldiers dying, he's making a profit off of keeping the soldiers fed, that's something that simply HAS to be done whether they like the war or not.

reply

I agree completely!

reply

I don't agree with Adam being a bastard, but you're right about one thing; Cal should have left. I don't know what he stuck around for. He would have done his father and his brother a favor by leaving.


"Everyone you lost, and saved...
Nothing will remain. Cradle or grave."

reply

Agreed about Adam's character; he obviously has a favorite son and doesn't even try to hide it.
In regard to the bean money, I believe that the scene would've made more sense if Adam had rejected the money because he saw it as counting on a misfortune (the war) coming to pass (in order for the price to rise to cover Cal's investment price), and that betting on a misfortune is a sin.

reply

Agreed! Said exactly the same thing myself on another thread.

reply